Here is a quick primer on how to use the table below.
| Season | Date | Away Team | Away Score | Home Team | Home Score | Notes | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1893 | Thursday, February 22, 1894 | Cheyenne Central | 0 | University of Wyoming | 14 | LB | |
| 1895 | Saturday, November 23, 1895 | Laramie | 0 | UW JV | 24 | LB | |
| 1895 | Wednesday, January 1, 1896 | Laramie | 0 | UW JV | 40 | LB | |
| 1896 | Saturday, December 5, 1896 | Laramie | 4 | UW JV | 12 | LB | |
| 1897 | Saturday, December 25, 1897 | Laramie | 0 | UW third team | 16 | LDB | |
| 1898 | Thursday, November 24, 1898 | Laramie | 11 | UW third team | 6 | LDB | |
| 1901 | Friday, October 18, 1901 | Laramie | 12 | UW third team | 6 | LB/LREP | |
| 1901 | Friday, November 1, 1901 | Laramie | 0 | UW third team | 13 | LB | |
| 1902 | Saturday, December 13, 1902 | Cheyenne Central | 0 | University of Wyoming | 18 | CDL | |
| 1903 | Friday, October 16, 1903 | Laramie | 0 | University of Wyoming | 15 | LB | |
| 1904 | Saturday, October 15, 1904 | Cheyenne Central | 0 | University of Wyoming | 56 | WSWT | |
| 1904 | Saturday, October 22, 1904 | Northern Colorado (CO) | 0 | Cheyenne Central | 0 | tie | WSWT |
| 1904 | Saturday, November 5, 1904 | Cheyenne Central | 6 | University of Northern Colorado (CO) | 5 | WSWT | |
| 1904 | Tuesday, November 8, 1904 | University of Wyoming | 12 | Cheyenne Central | 6 | WSWT | |
| 1905 | Saturday, October 21, 1905 | Cheyenne Central | 6 | University of Northern Colorado (CO) | 6 | tie | CDL |
| 1905 | Saturday, October 28, 1905 | Northern Colorado (CO) | 0 | Cheyenne Central | 15 | CDL | |
| 1905 | Saturday, November 4, 1905 | Denver North (CO) | 16 | Cheyenne Central | 0 | CDL | |
| 1905 | Saturday, November 11, 1905 | University of Wyoming | Cheyenne Central | canceled | CDL | ||
| 1905 | Saturday, November 18, 1905 | Cheyenne Central | 0 | University of Wyoming | 10 | CDL | |
| 1905 | Thursday, November 30, 1905 | Cheyenne Central | 6 | North Platte (NE) | 6 | tie | CDL |
| 1906 | Saturday, October 13, 1906 | Cheyenne Central | 12 | Greeley (CO) | 12 | tie | CDL |
| 1906 | Friday, November 9, 1906 | Cheyenne Central | 0 | Loveland (CO) | 0 | tie | CDL |
| 1906 | Saturday, November 10, 1906 | Greeley (CO) | Cheyenne Central | canceled | CDL | ||
| 1906 | Saturday, November 10, 1906 | Cheyenne Central | Longmont (CO) | canceled | CDL | ||
| 1907 | Saturday, October 5, 1907 | Greeley (CO) | 6 | Cheyenne Central | 0 | CDL | |
| 1907 | Friday, October 11, 1907 | Loveland (CO) | 18 | Cheyenne Central | 0 | CDL | |
| 1907 | Friday, October 18, 1907 | Cheyenne Central | 6 | Loveland (CO) | 34 | CDL | |
| 1907 | Saturday, October 19, 1907 | Cheyenne Central | 0 | Longmont (CO) | 45 | CDL | |
| 1907 | Saturday, October 26, 1907 | Longmont (CO) | 17 | Cheyenne Central | 0 | CDL | |
| 1907 | Saturday, November 2, 1907 | Eaton (CO) | Cheyenne Central | not played | CDL | ||
| 1907 | Saturday, November 9, 1907 | Cheyenne Central | 5 | Greeley (CO) | 17 | CDL | |
| 1907 | Saturday, November 16, 1907 | Cheyenne Central | 6 | Fort Collins (CO) | 59 | FCWC | |
| 1907 | Saturday, November 23, 1907 | Cheyenne Central | Eaton (CO) | not played | CCHS | ||
| 1907 | Thursday, November 28, 1907 | Denver Barnes Commercial College (CO) | 0 | Cheyenne Central | 6 | CDL | |
| Season | Date | Away Team | Away Score | Home Team | Home Score | Notes | Source |