1920 OA
Laramie 4-2
Sheridan 4-2
Natrona 3-2
Cheyenne Central 4-3-2
Newcastle 1-3
Buffalo 0-1
University Prep 0-4-1
1919 OA
Sheridan 4-1
Laramie 2-1
Cheyenne Central 2-2
Buffalo 0-1
Natrona 0-1
1918 OA
No games played –
1917 OA
Sheridan 7-0
Laramie 1-1-1
Cheyenne Central 0-4-1
Buffalo 0-2
1916 OA
Laramie 3-0-3
Sheridan 2-2-1
Buffalo 0-1
Cheyenne Central 0-2
1915 OA
Sheridan 3-3
Laramie 3-5
Cheyenne Central 1-2
1914 OA
Wheatland 2-1
Cheyenne Central 2-4
Sheridan 1-2
Douglas 0-2
1913 OA
Douglas 2-0
Sheridan 1-0
Cheyenne Central 5-0-1
Wheatland 0-2
1912 OA
Sheridan 3-1-1
Cheyenne Central 4-4-1
Natrona 1-1
Wheatland 0-2
Laramie 0-3
1911 OA
Sheridan 4-0
Laramie 2-2-1
Cheyenne Central 0-3
1910 OA
Fort Washakie 2-0
Laramie 1-1-1
Sheridan 1-1
Lander 1-2-1
Natrona 0-1-1
Cheyenne Central 0-3-1
1909 OA
Natrona 2-1
Cheyenne Central 3-2-1
Douglas 1-3
Laramie 1-4
University Prep 0-1
1908 OA
Laramie 1-0
Cheyenne Central 4-1
Natrona 1-0-1
Lander 0-0-1
Douglas 0-1
University Prep 0-3
1907 OA
Cheyenne Central 1-7
1906 OA
Cheyenne Central 0-0-2
1905 OA
Cheyenne Central 1-2-2
1904 OA
Cheyenne Central 1-2-1
1903 OA
Laramie 0-1
1902 OA
Cheyenne Central 0-1
1901 OA
Laramie 1-1
1898-1900 OA
No games played –
1897 OA
Laramie 0-1
1896 OA
Laramie 0-1
1895 OA
Laramie 0-2
1894 OA
Cheyenne Central 0-1