| This page is sponsored by Buckle Up for Life.The simple act of wearing a seat belt is the single most effective way to prevent death and serious injury in a crash. Yet historically, Wyoming has one of the lowest seat belt compliance rates in the country. By working together to increase seat belt usage, we can protect people from needless death and injury. |
2024 conference: Class 2A East
2024 coach: Matt Conzelman
Colors: Black and orange
Stadium: Schoonmaker Field
| Program highlights |
| Records and superlatives |
| All-time record (since 1920): 347-459-25 (.433) All-time playoff record (since 1920): 5-25 Best season(s): 1940 (8-0) Worst season(s): 1923 (0-3), 1928 (0-2), 1973 (0-8-1), 2002 (0-9), 2003 (0-8), 2005 (0-8) and 2020 (0-8) Best-ever state finish: State runners-up, 1981 |
| Scoring records |
| Most points scored, game: 84, vs. Campbell County (12), O14/1921 Largest margin of victory: 72, vs. Campbell County (84-12), O14/1921 Most points allowed, game: 97, at Sheridan (Newcastle 0), O13/1923 Largest margin of defeat: 97, at Sheridan (97-0), O13/1923 |
| Streaks |
| Longest winning streak: 9 games, 1980-81 Longest unbeaten streak: 9 games (8-0-1), 1947-48 Longest winless/losing streak: 29 games, 2001-04 |
All records through the end of last season.
| Year-by-year results |
Columns are sortable. Click on the top of each column to sort by that column.
| Year | Class | Conference | Coach | W | L | T | Pct | PO W-L | State | TPS | TPA | APS | APA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1920 | One | none | James Greenwood | 1 | 3 | 0 | 0.250 | NA | 78 | 202 | 19.50 | 50.50 | |
| 1921 | One | Northeast | Morgan D. Davis | 3 | 4 | 0 | 0.429 | DNQ | 178 | 189 | 25.43 | 27.00 | |
| 1922 | One | Northeast | Hillard Cameron | 1 | 3 | 0 | 0.250 | DNQ | 40 | 106 | 10.00 | 26.50 | |
| 1923 | One | Northeast | Edward Hoel | 0 | 3 | 0 | 0.000 | DNQ | 14 | 116 | 4.67 | 38.67 | |
| 1924 | One | Northeast | Edward Hoel | 1 | 3 | 1 | 0.300 | DNQ | 69 | 72 | 13.80 | 14.40 | |
| 1925 | One | Northeast | Edward Hoel | 1 | 3 | 0 | 0.250 | DNQ | 16 | 49 | 4.00 | 12.25 | |
| 1926-27 | - | - | No team | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 1928 | One | Northeast | J.J. Wadsworth | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0.000 | DNQ | 0 | 142 | 0.00 | 71.00 | |
| 1929 | - | - | No team | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - | - |
| 1930 | One | Northeast | Ollie Hulse | 2 | 3 | 0 | 0.400 | DNQ | 42 | 54 | 8.40 | 10.80 | |
| 1931 | One | Northeast | Maurice Mann | 2 | 3 | 2 | 0.429 | DNQ4 | 119 | 75 | 17.00 | 10.71 | |
| 1932 | One | Northeast | Maurice Mann | 3 | 4 | 1 | 0.438 | DNQ4 | 64 | 116 | 8.00 | 14.50 | |
| 1933 | One | Northeast | Maurice Mann | 6 | 3 | 0 | 0.667 | DNQ4 | 148 | 96 | 16.44 | 10.67 | |
| 1934 | 11-man | Northeast | Maurice Mann | 4 | 3 | 0 | 0.571 | DNQ4 | 98 | 46 | 14.00 | 6.57 | |
| 1935 | 11-man | Northeast | Maurice Mann | 6 | 2 | 0 | 0.750 | DNQ4 | 150 | 84 | 18.75 | 10.50 | |
| 1936 | 11-man | Northeast | John Taylor | 2 | 5 | 1 | 0.313 | DNQ4 | 81 | 71 | 10.13 | 8.88 | |
| 1937 | 11-man | Northeast | Howard Strong | 2 | 6 | 0 | 0.250 | DNQ4 | 89 | 124 | 11.13 | 15.50 | |
| 1938 | 11-man | Northeast | Howard Strong | 1 | 7 | 1 | 0.167 | DNQ4 | 70 | 160 | 7.78 | 17.78 | |
| 1939 | 11-man | Northeast | R.G. Syverson | 2 | 7 | 0 | 0.222 | DNP | 115 | 155 | 12.78 | 17.22 | |
| 1940 | 11-man | Northeast | R.G. Syverson | 8 | 0 | 0 | 1.000 | DNP | 261 | 34 | 32.63 | 4.25 | |
| 1941 | 11-man | Northeast | R.G. Syverson | 6 | 2 | 0 | 0.750 | DNP | 137 | 41 | 17.13 | 5.13 | |
| 1942 | 11-man | Northeast | Wayne Brower | 5 | 4 | 1 | 0.550 | DNP | 110 | 83 | 12.22 | 9.22 | |
| 1943 | 11-man | Northeast | Herb Rector | 2 | 5 | 0 | 0.286 | DNP | 45 | 142 | 6.43 | 20.29 | |
| 1944 | 11-man | Northeast | John Ratigan | 2 | 7 | 0 | 0.222 | DNP | 99 | 177 | 11.00 | 19.67 | |
| 1945 | 11-man | Northeast | John Ratigan | 3 | 3 | 2 | 0.500 | DNP | 85 | 69 | 10.63 | 8.63 | |
| 1946 | 11-man | Northeast | John Ratigan | 3 | 4 | 1 | 0.438 | DNP | 66 | 84 | 8.25 | 10.50 | |
| 1947 | 11-man | Northeast | John Ratigan | 4 | 2 | 2 | 0.625 | DNP | 113 | 76 | 14.13 | 9.50 | |
| 1948 | A | Northeast | John Ratigan | 7 | 2 | 1 | 0.750 | 0-1 | SF | 133 | 121 | 14.78 | 13.44 |
| 1949 | A | Northeast | John Ratigan | 8 | 2 | 0 | 0.800 | 0-1 | SF | 195 | 85 | 19.50 | 8.50 |
| 1950 | A | Northeast | John Ratigan | 2 | 7 | 0 | 0.222 | DNQ4 | 92 | 139 | 10.22 | 15.44 | |
| 1951 | A | Northeast | John Ratigan | 2 | 6 | 0 | 0.250 | DNQ4 | 77 | 158 | 9.63 | 19.75 | |
| 1952 | A | Northeast | Bill Baker | 7 | 1 | 1 | 0.833 | DNQ4 | 136 | 46 | 15.11 | 5.11 | |
| 1953 | A | Northeast | Bill Baker | 3 | 6 | 0 | 0.333 | DNQ4 | 78 | 150 | 8.67 | 16.67 | |
| 1954 | A | Northeast | Bill Baker | 5 | 1 | 1 | 0.786 | DNQ4 | 118 | 42 | 16.86 | 6.00 | |
| 1955 | A | Northeast | Bill Morgan | 6 | 2 | 1 | 0.722 | 0-1 | SF | 206 | 112 | 22.89 | 12.44 |
| 1956 | A | Absaraka/NE District | Robert Brown | 6 | 2 | 1 | 0.722 | 0-1 | SF | 169 | 52 | 18.78 | 5.78 |
| 1957 | A | Absaraka/NE District | Robert Brown | 5 | 4 | 1 | 0.550 | 0-1 | SF | 118 | 131 | 11.80 | 13.10 |
| 1958 | A | Absaraka/NE District | Robert Brown | 8 | 2 | 0 | 0.800 | 0-1 | SF | 191 | 83 | 19.10 | 8.30 |
| 1959 | A | Absaraka/NE District | Robert Brown | 5 | 3 | 1 | 0.611 | 0-1 | SF | 157 | 105 | 17.44 | 11.67 |
| 1960 | A | Absaraka/NE District | Robert Brown | 3 | 5 | 0 | 0.375 | DNQ4 | 118 | 161 | 14.75 | 20.13 | |
| 1961 | A | Absaraka/NE District | Robert Brown | 2 | 5 | 1 | 0.313 | DNQ4 | 75 | 156 | 9.38 | 19.50 | |
| 1962 | A | Absaraka | Robert Brown | 7 | 2 | 0 | 0.778 | DNP | 239 | 94 | 26.56 | 10.44 | |
| 1963 | A | Absaraka | Robert Brown | 4 | 3 | 2 | 0.556 | DNP | 142 | 77 | 15.78 | 8.56 | |
| 1964 | A | Absaraka | Gary Campbell | 5 | 3 | 0 | 0.625 | DNP | 90 | 105 | 11.25 | 13.13 | |
| 1965 | A | Absaraka | Harry Reed | 6 | 1 | 1 | 0.813 | DNP | 138 | 46 | 17.25 | 5.75 | |
| 1966 | A | Absaraka | Harry Reed | 3 | 6 | 0 | 0.333 | DNP | 102 | 208 | 11.33 | 23.11 | |
| 1967 | A | Absaraka | Harry Reed | 7 | 2 | 0 | 0.778 | DNP | 215 | 79 | 23.89 | 8.78 | |
| 1968 | A | Absaraka | Harry Reed | 4 | 4 | 0 | 0.500 | DNP | 127 | 63 | 15.88 | 7.88 | |
| 1969 | A | Absaraka | Ron tenBensel | 4 | 5 | 0 | 0.444 | DNP | 189 | 178 | 21.00 | 19.78 | |
| 1970 | A | Absaraka | Ron tenBensel | 6 | 3 | 0 | 0.667 | DNP | 212 | 139 | 23.56 | 15.44 | |
| 1971 | A | Absaraka | Ron tenBensel | 4 | 3 | 1 | 0.563 | DNP | 177 | 113 | 22.13 | 14.13 | |
| 1972 | A | Absaraka | Wes Weekly | 2 | 6 | 0 | 0.250 | DNP | 90 | 193 | 11.25 | 24.13 | |
| 1973 | A | Absaraka | Mark Fisher | 0 | 8 | 1 | 0.056 | DNP | 80 | 270 | 8.89 | 30.00 | |
| 1974 | A | Absaraka | Mark Fisher | 5 | 4 | 0 | 0.556 | DNP | 160 | 142 | 17.78 | 15.78 | |
| 1975 | A | Absaraka | Mark Fisher | 4 | 4 | 0 | 0.500 | DNQ2 | 184 | 124 | 23.00 | 15.50 | |
| 1976 | A | Absaraka | Mark Fisher | 4 | 4 | 0 | 0.500 | DNQ2 | 137 | 129 | 17.13 | 16.13 | |
| 1977 | A | Absaraka | Erv Wentling | 7 | 1 | 0 | 0.875 | DNQ2 | 169 | 57 | 21.13 | 7.13 | |
| 1978 | A | Absaraka | Erv Wentling | 7 | 1 | 0 | 0.875 | DNQ2 | 187 | 118 | 23.38 | 14.75 | |
| 1979 | A | Absaraka | Erv Wentling | 5 | 3 | 0 | 0.625 | DNQ2 | 107 | 135 | 13.38 | 16.88 | |
| 1980 | A | East | Erv Wentling | 6 | 2 | 0 | 0.750 | DNQ2 | 143 | 70 | 17.88 | 8.75 | |
| 1981 | A | East | Erv Wentling | 8 | 1 | 0 | 0.889 | 0-1 | RU | 139 | 48 | 15.44 | 5.33 |
| 1982 | A | East | Erv Wentling | 5 | 3 | 0 | 0.625 | DNQ2 | 102 | 79 | 12.75 | 9.88 | |
| 1983 | 3A | East | Erv Wentling | 4 | 4 | 0 | 0.500 | DNQ2 | 113 | 123 | 14.13 | 15.38 | |
| 1984 | 3A | East | Erv Wentling | 5 | 4 | 0 | 0.556 | DNQ2 | 215 | 131 | 23.89 | 14.56 | |
| 1985 | 3A | East | Erv Wentling | 2 | 7 | 0 | 0.222 | DNQ2 | 90 | 205 | 10.00 | 22.78 | |
| 1986 | 3A | East | Fred Morris | 2 | 7 | 0 | 0.222 | DNQ2 | 109 | 199 | 12.11 | 22.11 | |
| 1987 | 3A | East | Fred Morris | 1 | 7 | 0 | 0.125 | DNQ4 | 121 | 253 | 15.13 | 31.63 | |
| 1988 | 3A | East | Hunter Short | 1 | 7 | 0 | 0.125 | DNQ4 | 64 | 264 | 8.00 | 33.00 | |
| 1989 | 3A | East | Brett Weaver | 1 | 7 | 0 | 0.125 | DNQ4 | 65 | 268 | 8.13 | 33.50 | |
| 1990 | 2A | East | Terry Baker | 1 | 8 | 0 | 0.111 | 0-1 | QF | 83 | 275 | 9.22 | 30.56 |
| 1991 | 2A | East | Terry Baker | 3 | 5 | 0 | 0.375 | 0-1 | QF | 129 | 169 | 16.13 | 21.13 |
| 1992 | 2A | East | Terry Baker | 2 | 6 | 0 | 0.250 | 0-1 | QF | 120 | 183 | 15.00 | 22.88 |
| 1993 | 2A | North | Brett Weaver | 1 | 7 | 0 | 0.125 | 0-1 | QF | 83 | 228 | 10.38 | 28.50 |
| 1994 | 2A | North | Brett Weaver | 3 | 5 | 0 | 0.375 | 0-1 | QF | 96 | 176 | 12.00 | 22.00 |
| 1995 | 2A | North | Brett Weaver | 1 | 7 | 0 | 0.125 | 0-1 | QF | 54 | 161 | 6.75 | 20.13 |
| 1996 | 2A | North | Ed Neibauer | 2 | 7 | 0 | 0.222 | 1-1 | SF | 148 | 271 | 16.44 | 30.11 |
| 1997 | 2A | North | Ed Neibauer | 2 | 5 | 0 | 0.286 | DNQ4 | 132 | 195 | 18.86 | 27.86 | |
| 1998 | 2A | North | Ed Neibauer | 2 | 5 | 0 | 0.286 | DNQ4 | 133 | 185 | 19.00 | 26.43 | |
| 1999 | 2A | North | Mike Gregory | 2 | 6 | 0 | 0.250 | 0-1 | QF | 149 | 193 | 18.63 | 24.13 |
| 2000 | 2A | North | Mike Gregory | 1 | 6 | 0 | 0.143 | DNQ8 | 42 | 201 | 6.00 | 28.71 | |
| 2001 | 4A | none | Mike Gregory | 1 | 8 | 0 | 0.111 | DNQ8 | 63 | 241 | 7.00 | 26.78 | |
| 2002 | 4A | none | Mike Gregory | 0 | 9 | 0 | 0.000 | DNQ8 | 40 | 421 | 4.44 | 46.78 | |
| 2003 | 4A | none | Mike Gregory | 0 | 8 | 0 | 0.000 | DNQ8 | 95 | 313 | 11.88 | 39.13 | |
| 2004 | 4A | none | Mike Gregory | 1 | 7 | 0 | 0.125 | DNQ8 | 102 | 245 | 12.75 | 30.63 | |
| 2005 | 3A | East | Mike Gregory | 0 | 8 | 0 | 0.000 | DNQ8 | 117 | 338 | 14.63 | 42.25 | |
| 2006 | 3A | East | Mike Gregory | 6 | 3 | 0 | 0.667 | 0-1 | QF | 185 | 108 | 20.56 | 12.00 |
| 2007 | 3A | East | Mike Gregory | 2 | 6 | 0 | 0.250 | DNQ8 | 96 | 224 | 12.00 | 28.00 | |
| 2008 | 3A | East | Mike Gregory | 1 | 7 | 0 | 0.125 | DNQ8 | 78 | 243 | 9.75 | 30.38 | |
| 2009 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 1 | 8 | 0 | 0.111 | DNQ8 | 86 | 229 | 9.56 | 25.44 | |
| 2010 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 4 | 6 | 0 | 0.400 | 0-1 | QF | 162 | 206 | 16.20 | 20.60 |
| 2011 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 6 | 4 | 0 | 0.600 | 1-1 | SF | 215 | 128 | 21.50 | 12.80 |
| 2012 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 9 | 2 | 0 | 0.818 | 1-1 | SF | 303 | 172 | 27.55 | 15.64 |
| 2013 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 5 | 5 | 0 | 0.500 | 0-1 | QF | 334 | 219 | 33.40 | 21.90 |
| 2014 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 8 | 3 | 0 | 0.727 | 1-1 | SF | 320 | 243 | 29.09 | 22.09 |
| 2015 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 3 | 6 | 0 | 0.333 | DNQ8 | 178 | 221 | 19.78 | 24.56 | |
| 2016 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 6 | 5 | 0 | 0.545 | 1-1 | SF | 331 | 272 | 30.09 | 24.73 |
| 2017 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 5 | 5 | 0 | 0.500 | 0-1 | QF | 283 | 270 | 28.30 | 27.00 |
| 2018 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 1 | 8 | 0 | 0.111 | DNQ8 | 53 | 350 | 6.63 | 43.75 | |
| 2019 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 1 | 8 | 0 | 0.111 | DNQ8 | 112 | 365 | 12.44 | 40.56 | |
| 2020 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 0 | 8 | 0 | 0.000 | DNQ8 | 65 | 267 | 8.13 | 33.38 | |
| 2021 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 3 | 6 | 0 | 0.333 | DNQ8 | 121 | 213 | 13.44 | 23.67 | |
| 2022 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 4 | 5 | 0 | 0.444 | 0-1 | QF | 187 | 263 | 20.78 | 29.22 |
| 2023 | 2A | East | Matt Conzelman | 2 | 6 | 0 | 0.250 | DNQ8 | 129 | 257 | 16.13 | 32.13 |
| Game-by-game results |
Here is a quick primer on how to use the table below.
| Season | Date | Away Team | Away Score | Home Team | Home Score | Notes | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1920 | Saturday, September 25, 1920 | Edgemont (SD) | 64 | Newcastle | 0 | NNJ | |
| 1920 | Saturday, October 2, 1920 | Newcastle | 0 | Sheridan | 82 | SPO | |
| 1920 | Saturday, October 16, 1920 | Newcastle | 6 | Crawford (NE) | 33 | NNL | |
| 1920 | Friday, October 22, 1920 | Edgemont (SD) | 23 | Newcastle | 72 | NNL | |
| 1920 | Friday, November 5, 1920 | Buffalo | Newcastle | not played | NNLJ | ||
| 1921 | Friday, September 30, 1921 | Edgemont (SD) | 33 | Newcastle | 21 | NNL | |
| 1921 | Saturday, October 8, 1921 | Newcastle | 0 | Sheridan | 57 | SPO | |
| 1921 | Friday, October 14, 1921 | Campbell County | 12 | Newcastle | 84 | GN/NNL | |
| 1921 | Friday, October 21, 1921 | Newcastle | 0 | Edgemont (SD) | 28 | NNL/NJ | |
| 1921 | Friday, October 28, 1921 | Newcastle | 47 | Campbell County | 0 | GN | |
| 1921 | Friday, November 4, 1921 | Newcastle | 0 | Edgemont (SD) | 52 | NNL | |
| 1921 | Friday, November 11, 1921 | Newcastle | 26 | Buffalo | 7 | BB/NNL | |
| 1922 | Saturday, October 7, 1922 | Newcastle | 0 | Sheridan | 67 | CDT/WST | |
| 1922 | Saturday, October 14, 1922 | Newcastle | 0 | Crawford (NE) | 26 | NJ | |
| 1922 | Friday, October 20, 1922 | Edgemont (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 34 | NNL | |
| 1922 | Friday, October 27, 1922 | Campbell County | 13 | Newcastle | 6 | WST/GN | |
| 1922 | Saturday, November 4, 1922 | Newcastle | Edgemont (SD) | canceled | NJ | ||
| 1922 | Saturday, November 11, 1922 | Newcastle | Campbell County | canceled | GN | ||
| 1922 | Saturday, November 18, 1922 | Moorcroft | Newcastle | ||||
| 1922 | Friday, November 24, 1922 | Crawford (NE) | Newcastle | not played | CRT | ||
| 1923 | Friday, September 28, 1923 | Edgemont (SD) | Newcastle | not played | NNL | ||
| 1923 | Saturday, October 6, 1923 | Newcastle | 14 | Campbell County | 17 | NNL | |
| 1923 | Saturday, October 13, 1923 | Newcastle | 0 | Sheridan | 97 | SPE | |
| 1923 | Saturday, October 20, 1923 | Campbell County | 2 | Newcastle | 0 | NNL | |
| 1923 | Saturday, November 3, 1923 | Edgemont (SD) | Newcastle | canceled-snow | NNL | ||
| 1924 | Friday, September 26, 1924 | Newcastle | 2 | Campbell County | 6 | CDT/SPE/GN | |
| 1924 | Saturday, October 11, 1924 | Newcastle | 7 | Sheridan | 41 | SPE | |
| 1924 | Saturday, October 18, 1924 | Campbell County | 6 | Newcastle | 6 | tie | GN |
| 1924 | Friday, October 24, 1924 | Sundance | 0 | Newcastle | 48 | NNL | |
| 1924 | Friday, October 31, 1924 | Newcastle | 6 | Lusk | 19 | LH | |
| 1925 | Friday, October 9, 1925 | Campbell County | 12 | Newcastle | 0 | SPE/GNR | |
| 1925 | Saturday, October 17, 1925 | Newcastle | 0 | Sundance | 25 | NNL/ST | |
| 1925 | Friday, October 30, 1925 | Newcastle | 0 | Campbell County | 6 | GNR | |
| 1925 | Friday, November 6, 1925 | Sundance | 6 | Newcastle | 16 | NNL | |
| 1928 | Friday, September 28, 1928 | Newcastle | 0 | Campbell County | 93 | GNR | |
| 1928 | Saturday, October 27, 1928 | Sundance | 49 | Newcastle | 0 | ST | |
| 1928 | Monday, November 12, 1928 | Campbell County | Newcastle | not played | GNR | ||
| 1930 | Friday, October 3, 1930 | Newcastle | Campbell County | canceled-rain | NNL | ||
| 1930 | Friday, October 10, 1930 | Sundance | 25 | Newcastle | 6 | NNL | |
| 1930 | Friday, October 17, 1930 | Newcastle | 0 | Sundance | 12 | NNL | |
| 1930 | Friday, October 24, 1930 | Edgemont (SD) | 11 | Newcastle | 0 | NNL | |
| 1930 | Friday, October 31, 1930 | Custer (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 24 | NNL | |
| 1930 | Tuesday, November 11, 1930 | Newcastle | 12 | Custer (SD) | 6 | NNL | |
| 1931 | Friday, September 25, 1931 | Campbell County | 0 | Newcastle | 0 | tie | NNL |
| 1931 | Friday, October 2, 1931 | Manville | 0 | Newcastle | 67 | NNL | |
| 1931 | Friday, October 9, 1931 | Newcastle | 7 | Sundance | 25 | NNL | |
| 1931 | Friday, October 16, 1931 | Lead (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 33 | CTH/SP/NNL | |
| 1931 | Friday, October 23, 1931 | Sundance | 19 | Newcastle | 6 | WST/SP/NNL | |
| 1931 | Friday, October 30, 1931 | Edgemont (SD) | 25 | Newcastle | 0 | NNL | |
| 1931 | Wednesday, November 11, 1931 | Newcastle | 6 | Campbell County | 6 | tie | CTH/NNL |
| 1932 | Friday, September 23, 1932 | Newcastle | 0 | Campbell County | 13 | CTH/SP | |
| 1932 | Saturday, October 1, 1932 | Newcastle | 0 | Sheridan | 48 | SP | |
| 1932 | Friday, October 7, 1932 | Newcastle | 6 | Custer (SD) | 18 | NNL | |
| 1932 | Friday, October 14, 1932 | Campbell County | 7 | Newcastle | 13 | SP | |
| 1932 | Tuesday, October 25, 1932 | Sundance | 0 | Newcastle | 13 | ST | |
| 1932 | Monday, October 31, 1932 | Manville | 0 | Newcastle | 26 | NNL | |
| 1932 | Friday, November 4, 1932 | Newcastle | 0 | Edgemont (SD) | 24 | NNL | |
| 1932 | Friday, November 11, 1932 | Custer (SD) | 6 | Newcastle | 6 | tie | NNL |
| 1933 | Friday, September 15, 1933 | Newcastle | 0 | Campbell County | 13 | CTH | |
| 1933 | Friday, September 22, 1933 | Lusk | 0 | Newcastle | 35 | LH | |
| 1933 | Friday, September 29, 1933 | Campbell County | 6 | Newcastle | 7 | NNL | |
| 1933 | Friday, October 13, 1933 | Custer (SD) | 6 | Newcastle | 33 | NNL | |
| 1933 | Wednesday, October 18, 1933 | Newcastle | 13 | Sundance | 7 | NNL | |
| 1933 | Saturday, October 21, 1933 | Newcastle | 20 | Lead (SD) | 6 | SP/NNL | |
| 1933 | Saturday, October 28, 1933 | Newcastle | 12 | Sheridan | 40 | CTH/SP | |
| 1933 | Friday, November 3, 1933 | Edgemont (SD) | 12 | Newcastle | 0 | NNL | |
| 1933 | Saturday, November 11, 1933 | Newcastle | 28 | Custer (SD) | 6 | NNNL | |
| 1934 | Friday, September 21, 1934 | Newcastle | 12 | Lusk | 0 | SP/WST | |
| 1934 | Friday, September 28, 1934 | Edgemont (SD) | 18 | Newcastle | 2 | NNLJ | |
| 1934 | Friday, October 5, 1934 | Newcastle | 0 | Campbell County | 12 | SP/WST | |
| 1934 | Friday, October 12, 1934 | Newcastle | 33 | Custer (SD) | 0 | NNLJ | |
| 1934 | Saturday, October 20, 1934 | Buffalo | Newcastle | canceled | NNLJ | ||
| 1934 | Friday, October 26, 1934 | Sundance | 0 | Newcastle | 12 | NNLJ | |
| 1934 | Friday, November 2, 1934 | Newcastle | 0 | Edgemont (SD) | 14 | NNLJ | |
| 1934 | Monday, November 12, 1934 | Custer (SD) | 2 | Newcastle | 39 | NNLJ | |
| 1935 | Friday, September 20, 1935 | Lusk | 0 | Newcastle | 42 | NNLJ | |
| 1935 | Friday, September 27, 1935 | Custer (SD) | 6 | Newcastle | 48 | NNLJ | |
| 1935 | Saturday, October 5, 1935 | Campbell County | 0 | Newcastle | 14 | NNLJ | |
| 1935 | Saturday, October 19, 1935 | Newcastle | 26 | Buffalo | 0 | CTH/SP | |
| 1935 | Friday, October 25, 1935 | Newcastle | 13 | Sundance | 0 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1935 | Friday, November 1, 1935 | Edgemont (SD) | 34 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH | |
| 1935 | Monday, November 11, 1935 | Newcastle | 7 | Custer (SD) | 6 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1935 | Saturday, November 16, 1935 | Sheridan | 38 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH | |
| 1936 | Friday, September 25, 1936 | Newcastle | 0 | Hot Springs (SD) | 6 | NNLJ | |
| 1936 | Friday, October 2, 1936 | Newcastle | 7 | Campbell County | 13 | CTH/RSDR | |
| 1936 | Friday, October 9, 1936 | Edgemont (SD) | 13 | Newcastle | 0 | NNLJ | |
| 1936 | Friday, October 16, 1936 | Buffalo | 13 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH | |
| 1936 | Friday, October 23, 1936 | Upton | 0 | Newcastle | 33 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1936 | Friday, October 30, 1936 | Newcastle | 0 | Edgemont (SD) | 26 | NNLJ | |
| 1936 | Wednesday, November 11, 1936 | Custer (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 41 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1936 | Friday, November 13, 1936 | Newcastle | Upton | canceled | NNLJ | ||
| 1936 | Saturday, November 14, 1936 | Sundance | 0 | Newcastle | 0 | tie | NNLJ/SP |
| 1937 | Friday, September 17, 1937 | Lingle | 13 | Newcastle | 12 | CTH/SP/NNLJ | |
| 1937 | Friday, September 24, 1937 | Hot Springs (SD) | 19 | Newcastle | 13 | CTH/SP/NNLJ | |
| 1937 | Friday, October 1, 1937 | Newcastle | 6 | Upton | 14 | WCG | |
| 1937 | Saturday, October 9, 1937 | Newcastle | 7 | Sundance | 20 | CTH/ST | |
| 1937 | Friday, October 15, 1937 | Newcastle | 6 | Lusk | 0 | CTH/LH | |
| 1937 | Friday, October 22, 1937 | Upton | Newcastle | canceled | CTH/WCG | ||
| 1937 | Friday, October 29, 1937 | Edgemont (SD) | 39 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1937 | Friday, November 5, 1937 | Campbell County | 0 | Newcastle | 32 | CTH | |
| 1937 | Thursday, November 11, 1937 | Newcastle | 13 | Custer (SD) | 19 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1938 | Friday, September 16, 1938 | Manville | 6 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH/SP | |
| 1938 | Friday, September 23, 1938 | Newcastle | 7 | Hot Springs (SD) | 30 | NNLJ | |
| 1938 | Friday, September 30, 1938 | Upton | 0 | Newcastle | 30 | CTH/SP/WCG | |
| 1938 | Friday, October 7, 1938 | Newcastle | 7 | Midwest | 32 | CTH | |
| 1938 | Thursday, October 13, 1938 | Lusk | 6 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH | |
| 1938 | Friday, October 21, 1938 | Sundance | 33 | Newcastle | 12 | CTH/ST | |
| 1938 | Friday, October 28, 1938 | Newcastle | 14 | Edgemont (SD) | 20 | NNLJ/RCJ | |
| 1938 | Tuesday, November 8, 1938 | Newcastle | 0 | Campbell County | 0 | tie | GNR |
| 1938 | Friday, November 11, 1938 | Custer (SD) | 33 | Newcastle | 0 | NNLJ | |
| 1939 | Friday, September 15, 1939 | Lead (SD) | 36 | Newcastle | 0 | NNLJ | |
| 1939 | Friday, September 22, 1939 | Newcastle | 26 | Upton | 6 | WCG | |
| 1939 | Friday, September 29, 1939 | Campbell County | 6 | Newcastle | 2 | CTH/SP | |
| 1939 | Friday, October 6, 1939 | Manville | 6 | Newcastle | 48 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1939 | Friday, October 13, 1939 | Newcastle | 7 | Sundance | 13 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1939 | Friday, October 20, 1939 | Newcastle | 6 | Lusk | 19 | NNLJ | |
| 1939 | Friday, October 27, 1939 | Edgemont (SD) | 24 | Newcastle | 14 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1939 | Friday, November 3, 1939 | Newcastle | 6 | Buffalo | 25 | CTH/SP | |
| 1939 | Saturday, November 11, 1939 | Newcastle | 6 | Custer (SD) | 20 | NNLJ | |
| 1940 | Friday, September 20, 1940 | Upton | 0 | Newcastle | 55 | SP/WCG/NNLJ | |
| 1940 | Friday, September 27, 1940 | Newcastle | 20 | Campbell County | 15 | CTH/GNR/NNLJ | |
| 1940 | Thursday, October 3, 1940 | Newcastle | 39 | Rapid City JV (SD) | 0 | NNLJ | |
| 1940 | Friday, October 11, 1940 | Sundance | 0 | Newcastle | 33 | CTH/WE | |
| 1940 | Wednesday, October 16, 1940 | Lusk | 7 | Newcastle | 34 | CTH/LH | |
| 1940 | Friday, October 25, 1940 | Newcastle | 13 | Edgemont (SD) | 12 | CTH/WE | |
| 1940 | Friday, November 1, 1940 | Buffalo | 0 | Newcastle | 20 | CTH | |
| 1940 | Monday, November 11, 1940 | Custer (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 47 | NNLJ | |
| 1941 | Friday, September 12, 1941 | Hot Springs (SD) | 12 | Newcastle | 6 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1941 | Friday, September 19, 1941 | Belle Fourche (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 7 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1941 | Friday, September 26, 1941 | Campbell County | 0 | Newcastle | 19 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1941 | Thursday, October 2, 1941 | Midwest | 29 | Newcastle | 9 | CTH | |
| 1941 | Saturday, October 11, 1941 | Newcastle | 32 | Rapid City JV (SD) | 0 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1941 | Friday, October 17, 1941 | Newcastle | Sundance | canceled | NNLJ | ||
| 1941 | Friday, October 24, 1941 | Edgemont (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 33 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1941 | Friday, October 31, 1941 | Newcastle | 13 | Buffalo | 0 | NNLJ | |
| 1941 | Tuesday, November 11, 1941 | Newcastle | 18 | Custer (SD) | 0 | NNLJ | |
| 1942 | Friday, September 18, 1942 | Newcastle | 0 | Belle Fourche (SD) | 18 | NNLJ | |
| 1942 | Friday, September 25, 1942 | Sundance | 0 | Newcastle | 34 | SP | |
| 1942 | Friday, October 2, 1942 | Newcastle | 0 | Midwest | 6 | CTH | |
| 1942 | Tuesday, October 6, 1942 | Upton | 7 | Newcastle | 32 | WCG | |
| 1942 | Friday, October 9, 1942 | Newcastle | 20 | Campbell County | 0 | CTH/SP | |
| 1942 | Friday, October 16, 1942 | Douglas | 19 | Newcastle | 6 | DB | |
| 1942 | Friday, October 23, 1942 | Newcastle | 6 | Edgemont (SD) | 0 | NNLJ | |
| 1942 | Friday, October 30, 1942 | Buffalo | Newcastle | Newcastle win by forfeit | NNLJ | ||
| 1942 | Friday, October 30, 1942 | Lusk | 12 | Newcastle | 12 | tie | LH |
| 1942 | Tuesday, November 3, 1942 | Newcastle | Upton | canceled | WCG | ||
| 1942 | Wednesday, November 11, 1942 | Custer (SD) | 21 | Newcastle | 0 | NNLJ | |
| 1943 | Friday, September 24, 1943 | Newcastle | 6 | Sundance | 12 | CTH/WST/NNLJ | |
| 1943 | Friday, October 1, 1943 | Midwest | 18 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH | |
| 1943 | Friday, October 8, 1943 | Campbell County | 12 | Newcastle | 7 | NNLJ | |
| 1943 | Thursday, October 14, 1943 | Newcastle | 19 | Upton | 7 | NNLJ | |
| 1943 | Tuesday, October 19, 1943 | Douglas | Newcastle | not played | NHS | ||
| 1943 | Friday, October 22, 1943 | Edgemont (SD) | 47 | Newcastle | 0 | NNLJ | |
| 1943 | Friday, October 29, 1943 | Newcastle | 13 | Provo (SD) | 6 | NNLJ | |
| 1943 | Thursday, November 11, 1943 | Newcastle | 0 | Custer (SD) | 40 | NNLJ | |
| 1944 | Friday, September 15, 1944 | Newcastle | 0 | Belle Fourche (SD) | 39 | NNLJ | |
| 1944 | Friday, September 22, 1944 | Sundance | 13 | Newcastle | 33 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1944 | Friday, September 29, 1944 | Newcastle | 6 | Midwest | 31 | CTH | |
| 1944 | Friday, October 6, 1944 | Newcastle | 0 | Campbell County | 7 | CTH/GNR/NHS | |
| 1944 | Friday, October 13, 1944 | Upton | 26 | Newcastle | 7 | NNLJ/WCG | |
| 1944 | Friday, October 20, 1944 | Newcastle | 13 | Douglas | 14 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1944 | Friday, October 27, 1944 | Provo (SD) | 6 | Newcastle | 19 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1944 | Friday, November 3, 1944 | Newcastle | 6 | Edgemont (SD) | 15 | NNLJ | |
| 1944 | Saturday, November 11, 1944 | Custer (SD) | 26 | Newcastle | 6 | NNLJ | |
| 1945 | Friday, September 21, 1945 | Newcastle | 19 | Sundance | 7 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1945 | Friday, September 28, 1945 | Newcastle | 0 | Custer (SD) | 0 | tie | CTH/NNLJ |
| 1945 | Friday, October 5, 1945 | Campbell County | 29 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH/GNR | |
| 1945 | Friday, October 12, 1945 | Newcastle | 0 | Upton | 0 | tie | CTH/NNLJ |
| 1945 | Friday, October 19, 1945 | Midwest | 14 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH | |
| 1945 | Friday, October 26, 1945 | Newcastle | 38 | Provo (SD) | 7 | NNLJ | |
| 1945 | Friday, November 2, 1945 | Buffalo | 0 | Newcastle | 28 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1945 | Thursday, November 8, 1945 | Edgemont (SD) | 12 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1946 | Friday, September 20, 1946 | Sundance | 0 | Newcastle | 27 | CTH/ST | |
| 1946 | Friday, September 27, 1946 | Custer (SD) | 13 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH/SP | |
| 1946 | Friday, October 4, 1946 | Newcastle | 7 | Campbell County | 7 | tie | CTH/WST |
| 1946 | Friday, October 11, 1946 | Upton | 0 | Newcastle | 7 | CTH | |
| 1946 | Friday, October 18, 1946 | Newcastle | 6 | Midwest | 19 | CTH | |
| 1946 | Friday, October 25, 1946 | Provo (SD) | 25 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH/SP | |
| 1946 | Friday, November 1, 1946 | Newcastle | 7 | Buffalo | 20 | CTH/WST | |
| 1946 | Thursday, November 7, 1946 | Newcastle | 12 | Edgemont (SD) | 0 | NNLJ | |
| 1947 | Friday, September 12, 1947 | Newcastle | 12 | Lead (SD) | 6 | CTH/SP | |
| 1947 | Friday, September 19, 1947 | Newcastle | 31 | Sundance | 0 | CTH/SP | |
| 1947 | Wednesday, October 1, 1947 | Campbell County | 18 | Newcastle | 24 | CTH/SP | |
| 1947 | Tuesday, October 7, 1947 | Newcastle | 0 | Custer (SD) | 19 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1947 | Friday, October 10, 1947 | Newcastle | 7 | Upton | 7 | tie | CTH/WST/SP |
| 1947 | Friday, October 17, 1947 | Midwest | 7 | Newcastle | 7 | tie | CTH |
| 1947 | Friday, October 24, 1947 | Newcastle | 7 | Provo (SD) | 13 | CTH | |
| 1947 | Friday, October 31, 1947 | Buffalo | 6 | Newcastle | 25 | CTH | |
| 1947 | Friday, November 7, 1947 | Edgemont (SD) | Newcastle | canceled-snow | NNLJ | ||
| 1948 | Friday, September 10, 1948 | Lead (SD) | 7 | Newcastle | 12 | CTH/WST | |
| 1948 | Friday, September 24, 1948 | Custer (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 6 | CTH/WST | |
| 1948 | Friday, October 1, 1948 | Newcastle | 18 | Campbell County | 6 | CTH | |
| 1948 | Wednesday, October 6, 1948 | Upton | 18 | Newcastle | 19 | CTH | |
| 1948 | Saturday, October 16, 1948 | Newcastle | 13 | Midwest | 12 | CTH | |
| 1948 | Friday, October 22, 1948 | Provo (SD) | 20 | Newcastle | 20 | tie | CTH/WST |
| 1948 | Tuesday, October 26, 1948 | Sundance | 0 | Newcastle | 25 | CTH/WST/ST | |
| 1948 | Friday, October 29, 1948 | Newcastle | Buffalo | Newcastle win by forfeit | CTH | ||
| 1948 | Friday, November 5, 1948 | Newcastle | 7 | Edgemont (SD) | 12 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1948 | Thursday, November 11, 1948 | Newcastle | 13 | Lander | 46 | A SF | CTH |
| 1949 | Friday, September 9, 1949 | Newcastle | 6 | Hot Springs (SD) | 26 | CTH/CMS | |
| 1949 | Friday, September 16, 1949 | Newcastle | 28 | Sundance | 14 | CTH/SP | |
| 1949 | Friday, September 23, 1949 | Newcastle | 25 | Custer (SD) | 0 | CTH/SP | |
| 1949 | Friday, September 30, 1949 | Campbell County | 0 | Newcastle | 27 | CTH | |
| 1949 | Wednesday, October 5, 1949 | Newcastle | 26 | Upton | 2 | CTH/SP | |
| 1949 | Friday, October 14, 1949 | Midwest | 0 | Newcastle | 19 | CTH | |
| 1949 | Friday, October 21, 1949 | Newcastle | 25 | Provo (SD) | 6 | NNLJ | |
| 1949 | Friday, October 28, 1949 | Buffalo | 12 | Newcastle | 26 | CTH | |
| 1949 | Friday, November 4, 1949 | Edgemont (SD) | 6 | Newcastle | 13 | CTH/SP | |
| 1949 | Friday, November 11, 1949 | Newcastle | 0 | Cody | 19 | A SF | CTH |
| 1950 | Friday, September 8, 1950 | Hot Springs (SD) | 7 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1950 | Friday, September 15, 1950 | Sundance | 13 | Newcastle | 26 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1950 | Friday, September 22, 1950 | Custer (SD) | 18 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH | |
| 1950 | Friday, September 29, 1950 | Newcastle | 0 | Campbell County | 7 | CTH | |
| 1950 | Wednesday, October 4, 1950 | Upton | 0 | Newcastle | 27 | CTH | |
| 1950 | Friday, October 13, 1950 | Newcastle | 0 | Midwest | 13 | CTH | |
| 1950 | Friday, October 20, 1950 | Provo (SD) | 19 | Newcastle | 14 | CTH | |
| 1950 | Friday, October 27, 1950 | Newcastle | 19 | Buffalo | 35 | CTH | |
| 1950 | Friday, November 3, 1950 | Newcastle | 6 | Edgemont (SD) | 27 | CTH | |
| 1951 | Friday, September 14, 1951 | Sundance | 0 | Newcastle | 12 | CTH | |
| 1951 | Friday, September 21, 1951 | Newcastle | 6 | Custer (SD) | 19 | CTH/RSDR | |
| 1951 | Friday, September 28, 1951 | Campbell County | 26 | Newcastle | 12 | CTH | |
| 1951 | Wednesday, October 3, 1951 | Newcastle | 0 | Upton | 12 | CTH | |
| 1951 | Friday, October 12, 1951 | Midwest | 6 | Newcastle | 13 | CTH | |
| 1951 | Friday, October 19, 1951 | Newcastle | 20 | Provo (SD) | 39 | CTH | |
| 1951 | Friday, October 26, 1951 | Buffalo | 38 | Newcastle | 6 | CTH | |
| 1951 | Friday, November 2, 1951 | Edgemont (SD) | 18 | Newcastle | 8 | CTH | |
| 1952 | Friday, September 19, 1952 | Custer (SD) | 7 | Newcastle | 7 | tie | CTH |
| 1952 | Friday, September 26, 1952 | Newcastle | 0 | Campbell County | 7 | CTH | |
| 1952 | Friday, October 3, 1952 | Upton | 0 | Newcastle | 14 | CTH | |
| 1952 | Wednesday, October 8, 1952 | Newcastle | 7 | Midwest | 6 | CTH | |
| 1952 | Friday, October 17, 1952 | Lusk | 6 | Newcastle | 14 | CTH | |
| 1952 | Tuesday, October 21, 1952 | Sundance | 7 | Newcastle | 41 | make-up from game scheduled for S12 | CTH/SP |
| 1952 | Friday, October 24, 1952 | Newcastle | 26 | Buffalo | 6 | CTH | |
| 1952 | Friday, October 31, 1952 | Newcastle | 14 | Edgemont (SD) | 0 | CTH | |
| 1952 | Tuesday, November 11, 1952 | Pine Ridge (SD) | 7 | Newcastle | 13 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1953 | Friday, September 4, 1953 | Newcastle | 6 | Spearfish (SD) | 46 | CTH | |
| 1953 | Friday, September 11, 1953 | Newcastle | 13 | Sundance | 0 | CTH | |
| 1953 | Friday, September 18, 1953 | Newcastle | 6 | Custer (SD) | 13 | CTH | |
| 1953 | Friday, September 25, 1953 | Campbell County | 0 | Newcastle | 14 | CTH/SP | |
| 1953 | Friday, October 2, 1953 | Newcastle | 13 | Upton | 25 | CTH | |
| 1953 | Wednesday, October 7, 1953 | Midwest | 7 | Newcastle | 6 | CTH/MHS | |
| 1953 | Friday, October 16, 1953 | Newcastle | 7 | Lusk | 46 | CTH/SP | |
| 1953 | Friday, October 23, 1953 | Buffalo | 6 | Newcastle | 13 | CTH | |
| 1953 | Friday, October 30, 1953 | Edgemont (SD) | 7 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH | |
| 1954 | Friday, September 3, 1954 | Spearfish (SD) | 6 | Newcastle | 25 | CTH | |
| 1954 | Friday, September 10, 1954 | Sundance | 0 | Newcastle | 33 | CTH | |
| 1954 | Friday, September 24, 1954 | Newcastle | 6 | Campbell County | 6 | tie | CTH |
| 1954 | Friday, October 1, 1954 | Upton | 0 | Newcastle | 20 | CTH | |
| 1954 | Wednesday, October 6, 1954 | Newcastle | 21 | Midwest | 6 | CTH | |
| 1954 | Friday, October 15, 1954 | Lusk | 6 | Newcastle | 7 | CTH | |
| 1954 | Friday, October 22, 1954 | Newcastle | 6 | Buffalo | 18 | CTH | |
| 1954 | Friday, October 29, 1954 | Newcastle | Edgemont (SD) | canceled | NHS | ||
| 1955 | Friday, September 9, 1955 | Belle Fourche (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 7 | SP | |
| 1955 | Friday, September 16, 1955 | Newcastle | 6 | Douglas | 20 | CTH | |
| 1955 | Friday, September 23, 1955 | Campbell County | 7 | Newcastle | 20 | CTH | |
| 1955 | Friday, September 30, 1955 | Newcastle | 54 | Upton | 6 | CTH | |
| 1955 | Wednesday, October 5, 1955 | Midwest | 12 | Newcastle | 39 | CTH | |
| 1955 | Friday, October 14, 1955 | Newcastle | 34 | Spearfish (SD) | 20 | CTH | |
| 1955 | Friday, October 21, 1955 | Buffalo | 7 | Newcastle | 26 | CTH | |
| 1955 | Friday, October 28, 1955 | Edgemont (SD) | 20 | Newcastle | 20 | tie | CTH |
| 1955 | Friday, November 11, 1955 | Torrington | 20 | Newcastle | 0 | A SF | CTH |
| 1956 | Friday, September 7, 1956 | Newcastle | 6 | Belle Fourche (SD) | 0 | SP | |
| 1956 | Friday, September 14, 1956 | Douglas | 13 | Newcastle | 7 | CTH | |
| 1956 | Friday, September 21, 1956 | Newcastle | 26 | Campbell County | 6 | CTH | |
| 1956 | Friday, September 28, 1956 | Upton | 0 | Newcastle | 33 | CTH | |
| 1956 | Friday, October 5, 1956 | Newcastle | 31 | Midwest | 0 | CTH | |
| 1956 | Friday, October 12, 1956 | St. Mary's | 0 | Newcastle | 20 | CTH | |
| 1956 | Friday, October 19, 1956 | Newcastle | 27 | Buffalo | 0 | CTH | |
| 1956 | Friday, October 26, 1956 | Newcastle | 6 | Edgemont (SD) | 6 | tie | CTH |
| 1956 | Monday, November 5, 1956 | Lusk | Newcastle | postponed | CTH | ||
| 1956 | Saturday, November 10, 1956 | Newcastle | 13 | Torrington | 27 | A SF | CTH |
| 1957 | Friday, September 6, 1957 | Belle Fourche (SD) | 26 | Newcastle | 6 | SP | |
| 1957 | Friday, September 13, 1957 | Newcastle | 6 | Douglas | 7 | CTH | |
| 1957 | Friday, September 20, 1957 | Campbell County | 6 | Newcastle | 7 | CTH/SP | |
| 1957 | Friday, September 27, 1957 | Upton | 0 | Newcastle | 12 | CTH | |
| 1957 | Friday, October 4, 1957 | Midwest | 19 | Newcastle | 27 | CTH | |
| 1957 | Friday, October 11, 1957 | Newcastle | 6 | St. Mary's | 33 | CTH | |
| 1957 | Friday, October 18, 1957 | Buffalo | 13 | Newcastle | 27 | CTH | |
| 1957 | Friday, October 25, 1957 | Newcastle | 0 | Wheatland | 0 | tie | CTH |
| 1957 | Friday, November 1, 1957 | Newcastle | 20 | Lusk | 0 | CTH | |
| 1957 | Saturday, November 9, 1957 | Torrington | 27 | Newcastle | 7 | A SF | CTH/TT |
| 1958 | Friday, September 5, 1958 | Newcastle | 14 | Belle Fourche (SD) | 12 | CTH | |
| 1958 | Friday, September 12, 1958 | Douglas | 12 | Newcastle | 20 | CTH | |
| 1958 | Friday, September 19, 1958 | Newcastle | 18 | Campbell County | 0 | CTH | |
| 1958 | Friday, September 26, 1958 | Upton | 6 | Newcastle | 26 | CTH | |
| 1958 | Friday, October 3, 1958 | Newcastle | 33 | Midwest | 0 | CTH | |
| 1958 | Saturday, October 11, 1958 | St. Mary's | 0 | Newcastle | 26 | CTH | |
| 1958 | Friday, October 17, 1958 | Newcastle | 13 | Buffalo | 6 | CTH/SP | |
| 1958 | Friday, October 24, 1958 | Wheatland | 0 | Newcastle | 21 | CTH | |
| 1958 | Friday, October 31, 1958 | Lusk | 28 | Newcastle | 13 | CTH/SP | |
| 1958 | Saturday, November 8, 1958 | Newcastle | 7 | Torrington | 19 | A SF | CTH |
| 1959 | Friday, September 4, 1959 | Belle Fourche (SD) | 13 | Newcastle | 28 | SP | |
| 1959 | Friday, September 11, 1959 | Newcastle | 7 | Douglas | 34 | CTH | |
| 1959 | Friday, September 18, 1959 | Campbell County | 0 | Newcastle | 21 | CTH | |
| 1959 | Friday, September 25, 1959 | Newcastle | 0 | Lusk | 12 | CTH/SP | |
| 1959 | Friday, October 2, 1959 | Newcastle | 27 | Upton | 6 | CTH | |
| 1959 | Friday, October 9, 1959 | Newcastle | 13 | St. Mary's | 13 | tie | SP |
| 1959 | Friday, October 16, 1959 | Buffalo | 13 | Newcastle | 28 | CTH | |
| 1959 | Friday, October 23, 1959 | Newcastle | 26 | Wheatland | 7 | CTH | |
| 1959 | Saturday, November 14, 1959 | Douglas | 7 | Newcastle | 7 | A SF-Douglas wins playoff | CTH |
| 1960 | Friday, September 2, 1960 | Newcastle | 0 | Belle Fourche (SD) | 37 | CTH/NNLJ | |
| 1960 | Friday, September 9, 1960 | Newcastle | 19 | Douglas | 32 | CTH | |
| 1960 | Friday, September 16, 1960 | Newcastle | 13 | Campbell County | 0 | CTH | |
| 1960 | Friday, September 23, 1960 | Lusk | 20 | Newcastle | 14 | CTH | |
| 1960 | Friday, September 30, 1960 | Upton | 20 | Newcastle | 33 | CTH | |
| 1960 | Friday, October 7, 1960 | St. Mary's | 7 | Newcastle | 13 | CTH | |
| 1960 | Friday, October 14, 1960 | Newcastle | 7 | Buffalo | 19 | CTH | |
| 1960 | Friday, October 21, 1960 | Wheatland | 26 | Newcastle | 19 | CTH | |
| 1961 | Friday, September 8, 1961 | Newcastle | 13 | Douglas | 0 | CTH | |
| 1961 | Friday, September 15, 1961 | Campbell County | 18 | Newcastle | 6 | WE | |
| 1961 | Friday, September 22, 1961 | Newcastle | 6 | Lusk | 20 | WE | |
| 1961 | Friday, September 29, 1961 | Newcastle | 6 | Upton | 6 | tie | CTH |
| 1961 | Friday, October 6, 1961 | Newcastle | 12 | St. Mary's | 6 | WE | |
| 1961 | Friday, October 13, 1961 | Buffalo | 46 | Newcastle | 0 | CTH | |
| 1961 | Friday, October 20, 1961 | Newcastle | 18 | Wheatland | 32 | WE/NWDN | |
| 1961 | Friday, October 27, 1961 | Newell (SD) | 28 | Newcastle | 14 | CTH | |
| 1962 | Friday, August 31, 1962 | Newcastle | 7 | Torrington | 19 | CTH | |
| 1962 | Friday, September 7, 1962 | Douglas | 14 | Newcastle | 20 | CTH | |
| 1962 | Friday, September 14, 1962 | Newcastle | 19 | Campbell County | 0 | CTH | |
| 1962 | Friday, September 21, 1962 | Lusk | 34 | Newcastle | 0 | SP | |
| 1962 | Friday, September 28, 1962 | Upton | 0 | Newcastle | 38 | CTH | |
| 1962 | Friday, October 5, 1962 | St. Mary's | 6 | Newcastle | 47 | CTH | |
| 1962 | Friday, October 12, 1962 | Newcastle | 25 | Buffalo | 0 | CTH | |
| 1962 | Friday, October 19, 1962 | Wheatland | 21 | Newcastle | 51 | RR | |
| 1962 | Friday, October 26, 1962 | Newcastle | 32 | Provo (SD) | 0 | RR | |
| 1963 | Friday, August 30, 1963 | Torrington | 7 | Newcastle | 7 | tie | CST |
| 1963 | Friday, September 6, 1963 | Newcastle | 21 | Douglas | 6 | CST | |
| 1963 | Friday, September 13, 1963 | Campbell County | 13 | Newcastle | 12 | RR | |
| 1963 | Friday, September 20, 1963 | Newcastle | 7 | Lusk | 19 | CST | |
| 1963 | Friday, September 27, 1963 | Newcastle | 0 | Upton | 7 | CST | |
| 1963 | Wednesday, October 2, 1963 | Newcastle | 32 | St. Mary's | 6 | CST | |
| 1963 | Friday, October 11, 1963 | Buffalo | 0 | Newcastle | 18 | RR | |
| 1963 | Friday, October 18, 1963 | Newcastle | 13 | Wheatland | 13 | tie | RR |
| 1963 | Friday, October 25, 1963 | Provo (SD) | 6 | Newcastle | 32 | CST | |
| 1964 | Friday, September 4, 1964 | Douglas | 6 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 1964 | Friday, September 11, 1964 | Newcastle | 0 | Campbell County | 18 | CST | |
| 1964 | Friday, September 18, 1964 | Lusk | 6 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 1964 | Friday, September 25, 1964 | Upton | 12 | Newcastle | 7 | CST/RR | |
| 1964 | Friday, October 2, 1964 | Newcastle | 18 | St. Mary's | 7 | CST | |
| 1964 | Wednesday, October 7, 1964 | Newcastle | 0 | Buffalo | 24 | CST | |
| 1964 | Friday, October 16, 1964 | Wheatland | 19 | Newcastle | 20 | CST/RR | |
| 1964 | Friday, October 30, 1964 | Douglas | 13 | Newcastle | 18 | CST/RR | |
| 1965 | Friday, September 3, 1965 | Newcastle | 13 | Douglas | 6 | CST | |
| 1965 | Friday, September 10, 1965 | Campbell County | 0 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 1965 | Friday, September 17, 1965 | Newcastle | 6 | Lusk | 7 | CST | |
| 1965 | Friday, September 24, 1965 | Newcastle | 41 | Upton | 6 | CST | |
| 1965 | Friday, October 1, 1965 | Newcastle | 20 | St. Mary's | 0 | CST | |
| 1965 | Wednesday, October 6, 1965 | Buffalo | 13 | Newcastle | 13 | tie | CST |
| 1965 | Friday, October 15, 1965 | Newcastle | 13 | Wheatland | 7 | CST | |
| 1965 | Friday, October 29, 1965 | Douglas (SD) | 7 | Newcastle | 19 | CST | |
| 1966 | Friday, September 2, 1966 | Douglas | 40 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1966 | Friday, September 9, 1966 | Newcastle | 0 | Campbell County | 59 | CST | |
| 1966 | Friday, September 16, 1966 | Lusk | 12 | Newcastle | 19 | CST | |
| 1966 | Friday, September 23, 1966 | Upton | 14 | Newcastle | 32 | CST | |
| 1966 | Friday, September 30, 1966 | St. Mary's | 12 | Newcastle | 19 | CST | |
| 1966 | Wednesday, October 5, 1966 | Newcastle | 0 | Buffalo | 20 | RR | |
| 1966 | Friday, October 14, 1966 | Wheatland | 26 | Newcastle | 14 | CST/PCRT | |
| 1966 | Friday, October 21, 1966 | Rapid City JV (SD) | 13 | Newcastle | 12 | NNLJ | |
| 1966 | Friday, October 28, 1966 | Newcastle | 6 | Douglas (SD) | 12 | CST | |
| 1967 | Friday, September 1, 1967 | Douglas (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 46 | CST | |
| 1967 | Friday, September 8, 1967 | Lead (SD) | 20 | Newcastle | 24 | CST | |
| 1967 | Friday, September 15, 1967 | Newcastle | 25 | Douglas | 0 | CST | |
| 1967 | Friday, September 22, 1967 | Wheatland | 14 | Newcastle | 33 | SP | |
| 1967 | Friday, September 29, 1967 | St. Mary's | 0 | Newcastle | 33 | CST | |
| 1967 | Friday, October 6, 1967 | Newcastle | 13 | Buffalo | 0 | CST | |
| 1967 | Wednesday, October 11, 1967 | Torrington | 12 | Newcastle | 28 | CST | |
| 1967 | Friday, October 20, 1967 | Newcastle | 6 | Campbell County | 13 | CST | |
| 1967 | Friday, October 27, 1967 | Newcastle | 7 | Lusk | 20 | CST | |
| 1968 | Friday, September 6, 1968 | Newcastle | 7 | Lead (SD) | 12 | CST | |
| 1968 | Friday, September 13, 1968 | Douglas | 0 | Newcastle | 42 | CST | |
| 1968 | Friday, September 20, 1968 | Newcastle | 6 | Wheatland | 0 | CST | |
| 1968 | Friday, September 27, 1968 | Newcastle | 25 | St. Mary's | 0 | CST | |
| 1968 | Friday, October 4, 1968 | Buffalo | 7 | Newcastle | 27 | CST | |
| 1968 | Friday, October 11, 1968 | Newcastle | 7 | Torrington | 18 | CST | |
| 1968 | Friday, October 18, 1968 | Campbell County | 7 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1968 | Friday, October 25, 1968 | Lusk | 19 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1969 | Friday, September 5, 1969 | Lead (SD) | 12 | Newcastle | 8 | CST | |
| 1969 | Friday, September 12, 1969 | Newcastle | 32 | Douglas | 16 | CST | |
| 1969 | Friday, September 19, 1969 | Wheatland | 26 | Newcastle | 32 | CST | |
| 1969 | Friday, September 26, 1969 | St. Mary's | 0 | Newcastle | 50 | CST | |
| 1969 | Friday, October 3, 1969 | Newcastle | 8 | Buffalo | 23 | CST | |
| 1969 | Friday, October 10, 1969 | Torrington | 43 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1969 | Friday, October 17, 1969 | Newcastle | 6 | Campbell County | 21 | CST | |
| 1969 | Friday, October 24, 1969 | Newcastle | 33 | Lusk | 12 | CST | |
| 1969 | Friday, October 31, 1969 | Douglas (SD) | 25 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 1970 | Friday, September 4, 1970 | Newcastle | 24 | Lead (SD) | 16 | CST/SP | |
| 1970 | Friday, September 18, 1970 | Douglas | 12 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 1970 | Friday, September 25, 1970 | Newcastle | 27 | Wheatland | 8 | CST | |
| 1970 | Wednesday, September 30, 1970 | Newcastle | 52 | St. Mary's | 8 | CST | |
| 1970 | Friday, October 9, 1970 | Buffalo | 21 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 1970 | Friday, October 16, 1970 | Torrington | 40 | Newcastle | 8 | CST | |
| 1970 | Friday, October 23, 1970 | Greybull | 7 | Newcastle | 39 | CST | |
| 1970 | Friday, October 30, 1970 | Newcastle | 31 | Lusk | 6 | CST | |
| 1970 | Friday, November 6, 1970 | Newcastle | 6 | Douglas (SD) | 21 | SP | |
| 1971 | Friday, September 3, 1971 | Lead (SD) | 14 | Newcastle | 14 | tie | CST |
| 1971 | Friday, September 10, 1971 | Newcastle | 35 | Pine Bluffs | 8 | CST | |
| 1971 | Friday, September 17, 1971 | Newcastle | 20 | Douglas | 15 | CST | |
| 1971 | Friday, September 24, 1971 | Wheatland | 6 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1971 | Friday, October 1, 1971 | St. Mary's | 8 | Newcastle | 32 | CST | |
| 1971 | Wednesday, October 6, 1971 | Newcastle | 20 | Buffalo | 28 | CST | |
| 1971 | Friday, October 15, 1971 | Torrington | 34 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 1971 | Friday, October 22, 1971 | Newcastle | 44 | Greybull | 0 | CST | |
| 1971 | Friday, October 29, 1971 | Newcastle | Lusk | canceled-snow | CST | ||
| 1972 | Friday, September 1, 1972 | Newcastle | 6 | Lead (SD) | 29 | CST | |
| 1972 | Friday, September 8, 1972 | Pine Bluffs | 18 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 1972 | Friday, September 15, 1972 | Douglas | 21 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1972 | Friday, September 22, 1972 | Newcastle | 12 | Wheatland | 26 | CST | |
| 1972 | Friday, September 29, 1972 | Custer (SD) | 6 | Newcastle | 20 | CST | |
| 1972 | Thursday, October 5, 1972 | Buffalo | 32 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1972 | Friday, October 13, 1972 | Newcastle | 13 | Torrington | 55 | CST | |
| 1972 | Friday, October 27, 1972 | Lusk | 6 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 1973 | Friday, August 31, 1973 | Lead (SD) | 31 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1973 | Friday, September 7, 1973 | Newcastle | 6 | Sturgis (SD) | 26 | CST | |
| 1973 | Friday, September 14, 1973 | Newcastle | 13 | Douglas | 40 | CST | |
| 1973 | Friday, September 21, 1973 | Wheatland | 36 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1973 | Friday, September 28, 1973 | Newcastle | 0 | Custer (SD) | 6 | CST | |
| 1973 | Wednesday, October 3, 1973 | Newcastle | 16 | Buffalo | 45 | CST | |
| 1973 | Friday, October 12, 1973 | Torrington | 48 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1973 | Friday, October 19, 1973 | Newcastle | 13 | Lusk | 18 | CST | |
| 1973 | Friday, October 26, 1973 | Upton | 20 | Newcastle | 20 | tie | CST |
| 1974 | Friday, August 30, 1974 | Newcastle | 8 | Lead (SD) | 21 | CST | |
| 1974 | Friday, September 6, 1974 | Sturgis (SD) | 26 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 1974 | Friday, September 13, 1974 | Douglas | 3 | Newcastle | 17 | CST | |
| 1974 | Friday, September 20, 1974 | Newcastle | 23 | Wheatland | 0 | CST | |
| 1974 | Friday, September 27, 1974 | Newcastle | 13 | Glenrock | 26 | CST | |
| 1974 | Friday, October 4, 1974 | Buffalo | 12 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 1974 | Friday, October 11, 1974 | Newcastle | 0 | Torrington | 42 | CST | |
| 1974 | Friday, October 18, 1974 | Lusk | 6 | Newcastle | 47 | CST | |
| 1974 | Friday, October 25, 1974 | Newcastle | 27 | Upton | 6 | CST | |
| 1975 | Friday, September 5, 1975 | Lead (SD) | 14 | Newcastle | 21 | CST | |
| 1975 | Friday, September 12, 1975 | Newcastle | 17 | Douglas | 30 | CST | |
| 1975 | Friday, September 19, 1975 | Wheatland | 8 | Newcastle | 40 | CST | |
| 1975 | Friday, September 26, 1975 | Glenrock | 14 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1975 | Friday, October 3, 1975 | Newcastle | 10 | Buffalo | 15 | CST | |
| 1975 | Friday, October 10, 1975 | Torrington | 27 | Newcastle | 21 | CST | |
| 1975 | Friday, October 17, 1975 | Newcastle | 54 | Lusk | 8 | CST | |
| 1975 | Friday, October 24, 1975 | Upton | 8 | Newcastle | 21 | CST | |
| 1976 | Friday, August 27, 1976 | Newcastle | 14 | Upton | 20 | OT | CST |
| 1976 | Friday, September 3, 1976 | Newcastle | 14 | Lead (SD) | 28 | CST | |
| 1976 | Friday, September 10, 1976 | Douglas | 7 | Newcastle | 10 | CST | |
| 1976 | Friday, September 17, 1976 | Newcastle | 25 | Wheatland | 0 | CST | |
| 1976 | Friday, September 24, 1976 | Newcastle | 14 | Glenrock | 6 | CST | |
| 1976 | Friday, October 1, 1976 | Buffalo | 52 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1976 | Friday, October 8, 1976 | Newcastle | 6 | Torrington | 16 | CST | |
| 1976 | Friday, October 22, 1976 | Lusk | 0 | Newcastle | 47 | CST | |
| 1977 | Saturday, August 27, 1977 | Upton | 8 | Newcastle | 32 | CST | |
| 1977 | Friday, September 2, 1977 | Lead (SD) | 6 | Newcastle | 29 | CST | |
| 1977 | Friday, September 9, 1977 | Newcastle | 31 | Douglas | 14 | CST | |
| 1977 | Friday, September 16, 1977 | Wheatland | 7 | Newcastle | 26 | CST | |
| 1977 | Friday, September 23, 1977 | Glenrock | 9 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1977 | Friday, September 30, 1977 | Newcastle | 14 | Buffalo | 6 | CST | |
| 1977 | Friday, October 7, 1977 | Torrington | 7 | Newcastle | 10 | CST | |
| 1977 | Friday, October 21, 1977 | Newcastle | 27 | Lusk | 0 | CST | |
| 1978 | Friday, August 25, 1978 | Newcastle | 33 | Upton | 14 | CST | |
| 1978 | Friday, September 1, 1978 | Newcastle | 18 | Lead (SD) | 0 | CST | |
| 1978 | Friday, September 8, 1978 | Douglas | 32 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 1978 | Friday, September 15, 1978 | Newcastle | 16 | Wheatland | 12 | CST | |
| 1978 | Friday, September 22, 1978 | Newcastle | 21 | Glenrock | 7 | CST | |
| 1978 | Friday, September 29, 1978 | Buffalo | 26 | Newcastle | 27 | CST | |
| 1978 | Friday, October 6, 1978 | Newcastle | 34 | Torrington | 27 | CST | |
| 1978 | Friday, October 20, 1978 | Lusk | 0 | Newcastle | 25 | RR | |
| 1979 | Friday, August 24, 1979 | Newcastle | 7 | Upton | 6 | CST | |
| 1979 | Friday, August 31, 1979 | Lead (SD) | 8 | Newcastle | 17 | CST | |
| 1979 | Friday, September 7, 1979 | Newcastle | 7 | Kemmerer | 39 | CST | |
| 1979 | Friday, September 14, 1979 | Douglas | 41 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1979 | Friday, September 21, 1979 | Glenrock | 6 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1979 | Friday, September 28, 1979 | Newcastle | 19 | Buffalo | 23 | CST | |
| 1979 | Friday, October 12, 1979 | Torrington | 12 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 1979 | Friday, October 19, 1979 | Wheatland | 0 | Newcastle | 30 | CST | |
| 1980 | Friday, August 29, 1980 | Upton | 8 | Newcastle | 27 | CST | |
| 1980 | Friday, September 5, 1980 | Newcastle | 24 | Lead (SD) | 0 | CST | |
| 1980 | Friday, September 19, 1980 | Douglas | 14 | Newcastle | 19 | CST | |
| 1980 | Friday, September 26, 1980 | Newcastle | 20 | Glenrock | 13 | CST | |
| 1980 | Friday, October 3, 1980 | Buffalo | 21 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1980 | Friday, October 10, 1980 | Newcastle | 14 | Sheridan | 0 | CST | |
| 1980 | Friday, October 17, 1980 | Newcastle | 6 | Torrington | 7 | CST | |
| 1980 | Friday, October 24, 1980 | Newcastle | 27 | Wheatland | 7 | CST | |
| 1981 | Friday, August 28, 1981 | Newcastle | 27 | Upton | 6 | WCG | |
| 1981 | Friday, September 4, 1981 | Newcastle | 13 | Douglas (SD) | 6 | NNLJ | |
| 1981 | Friday, September 11, 1981 | Lead (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1981 | Friday, September 18, 1981 | Newcastle | 20 | Douglas | 0 | CST | |
| 1981 | Friday, September 25, 1981 | Glenrock | 3 | Newcastle | 20 | CST | |
| 1981 | Friday, October 2, 1981 | Newcastle | 21 | Buffalo | 0 | CST | |
| 1981 | Friday, October 16, 1981 | Torrington | 14 | Newcastle | 18 | CST | |
| 1981 | Friday, October 23, 1981 | Wheatland | 6 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1981 | Saturday, October 31, 1981 | Newcastle | 6 | Jackson | 13 | A Championship | CST |
| 1982 | Friday, August 27, 1982 | Upton | 6 | Newcastle | 40 | CST | |
| 1982 | Friday, September 3, 1982 | Douglas (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1982 | Friday, September 10, 1982 | Lead (SD) | 9 | Newcastle | 21 | CST | |
| 1982 | Friday, September 17, 1982 | Douglas | 3 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1982 | Friday, September 24, 1982 | Newcastle | 7 | Glenrock | 13 | CST | |
| 1982 | Friday, October 1, 1982 | Buffalo | 0 | Newcastle | 20 | CST | |
| 1982 | Friday, October 15, 1982 | Newcastle | 0 | Torrington | 12 | CST | |
| 1982 | Friday, October 22, 1982 | Newcastle | 0 | Wheatland | 36 | CST | |
| 1983 | Friday, September 2, 1983 | Newcastle | 19 | Douglas (SD) | 0 | CST | |
| 1983 | Friday, September 9, 1983 | Lead (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 33 | CST | |
| 1983 | Friday, September 23, 1983 | Newcastle | 6 | Douglas | 9 | CST | |
| 1983 | Friday, September 30, 1983 | Torrington | 6 | Newcastle | 15 | CST | |
| 1983 | Friday, October 7, 1983 | Newcastle | 14 | Alliance (NE) | 28 | CST | |
| 1983 | Friday, October 14, 1983 | Newcastle | 13 | Buffalo | 26 | CST | |
| 1983 | Friday, October 21, 1983 | Glenrock | 12 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 1983 | Friday, October 28, 1983 | Wheatland | 42 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1984 | Friday, August 31, 1984 | Douglas (SD) | 7 | Newcastle | 40 | CST | |
| 1984 | Friday, September 7, 1984 | Lead (SD) | 34 | Newcastle | 21 | CST | |
| 1984 | Friday, September 14, 1984 | Newcastle | 35 | Moorcroft | 15 | CST | |
| 1984 | Friday, September 21, 1984 | Douglas | 25 | Newcastle | 21 | CST | |
| 1984 | Friday, September 28, 1984 | Newcastle | 7 | Torrington | 19 | CST | |
| 1984 | Friday, October 5, 1984 | Thermopolis | 8 | Newcastle | 38 | CST | |
| 1984 | Friday, October 12, 1984 | Buffalo | 3 | Newcastle | 19 | CST | |
| 1984 | Friday, October 19, 1984 | Newcastle | 21 | Glenrock | 6 | CST | |
| 1984 | Friday, October 26, 1984 | Newcastle | 13 | Wheatland | 14 | CST | |
| 1985 | Friday, September 6, 1985 | Lead (SD) | 26 | Newcastle | 27 | CST | |
| 1985 | Friday, September 13, 1985 | Newcastle | 12 | Chadron (NE) | 23 | CST | |
| 1985 | Friday, September 20, 1985 | Moorcroft | 6 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 1985 | Friday, September 27, 1985 | Newcastle | 0 | Douglas | 20 | CST | |
| 1985 | Friday, October 4, 1985 | Torrington | 33 | Newcastle | 8 | CST | |
| 1985 | Saturday, October 12, 1985 | Newcastle | 0 | Thermopolis | 10 | CST | |
| 1985 | Friday, October 18, 1985 | Newcastle | 19 | Buffalo | 20 | CST | |
| 1985 | Friday, October 25, 1985 | Glenrock | 34 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1985 | Friday, November 1, 1985 | Wheatland | 33 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 1986 | Friday, September 5, 1986 | Newcastle | 0 | Lead (SD) | 14 | CST | |
| 1986 | Friday, September 12, 1986 | Chadron (NE) | 34 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1986 | Friday, September 19, 1986 | Newcastle | 21 | Moorcroft | 14 | CST | |
| 1986 | Friday, September 26, 1986 | Thermopolis | 0 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 1986 | Friday, October 3, 1986 | Newcastle | 0 | Torrington | 21 | CST | |
| 1986 | Friday, October 10, 1986 | Douglas | 34 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 1986 | Friday, October 17, 1986 | Buffalo | 27 | Newcastle | 21 | CST | |
| 1986 | Friday, October 24, 1986 | Newcastle | 21 | Glenrock | 38 | CST | |
| 1986 | Friday, October 31, 1986 | Newcastle | 14 | Wheatland | 17 | CST | |
| 1987 | Friday, September 4, 1987 | Lead (SD) | 7 | Newcastle | 10 | CST | |
| 1987 | Friday, September 11, 1987 | Chadron (NE) | 30 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1987 | Friday, September 18, 1987 | Newcastle | 20 | Glenrock | 47 | CST | |
| 1987 | Friday, September 25, 1987 | Newcastle | 23 | Thermopolis | 28 | CST | |
| 1987 | Friday, October 2, 1987 | Torrington | 40 | Newcastle | 21 | CST | |
| 1987 | Friday, October 9, 1987 | Newcastle | 14 | Douglas | 29 | CST | |
| 1987 | Friday, October 16, 1987 | Newcastle | 14 | Wheatland | 44 | CST | |
| 1987 | Friday, October 23, 1987 | Buffalo | 28 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 1988 | Friday, September 2, 1988 | Newcastle | 0 | Lead (SD) | 14 | CST | |
| 1988 | Friday, September 9, 1988 | Newcastle | 0 | Chadron (NE) | 43 | CST | |
| 1988 | Friday, September 16, 1988 | Glenrock | 35 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 1988 | Friday, September 23, 1988 | Newcastle | 17 | Spearfish (SD) | 7 | CST | |
| 1988 | Friday, September 30, 1988 | Newcastle | 6 | Torrington | 32 | CST | |
| 1988 | Friday, October 7, 1988 | Douglas | 26 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 1988 | Friday, October 14, 1988 | Wheatland | 66 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1988 | Friday, October 21, 1988 | Newcastle | 7 | Buffalo | 41 | CST | |
| 1989 | Friday, September 1, 1989 | Lead (SD) | 19 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1989 | Friday, September 8, 1989 | Newcastle | 3 | Glenrock | 0 | CST | |
| 1989 | Friday, September 15, 1989 | Newcastle | 14 | Custer (SD) | 58 | CST | |
| 1989 | Friday, September 22, 1989 | Spearfish (SD) | 33 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1989 | Friday, September 29, 1989 | Torrington | 40 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1989 | Friday, October 6, 1989 | Newcastle | 16 | Douglas | 24 | CST | |
| 1989 | Friday, October 13, 1989 | Newcastle | 19 | Wheatland | 53 | CST | |
| 1989 | Friday, October 20, 1989 | Buffalo | 41 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1990 | Friday, August 31, 1990 | Newcastle | 0 | Lead (SD) | 20 | CST | |
| 1990 | Friday, September 7, 1990 | Newcastle | 14 | Douglas (SD) | 43 | CST | |
| 1990 | Friday, September 14, 1990 | Newcastle | 27 | Custer (SD) | 35 | 3OT | CST |
| 1990 | Friday, September 21, 1990 | Newcastle | 8 | Spearfish (SD) | 21 | CST | |
| 1990 | Friday, September 28, 1990 | Wright | 0 | Newcastle | 34 | CST | |
| 1990 | Friday, October 5, 1990 | Glenrock | 42 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1990 | Friday, October 12, 1990 | Douglas | 34 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1990 | Friday, October 19, 1990 | Newcastle | 0 | Buffalo | 47 | CST | |
| 1990 | Saturday, October 27, 1990 | Newcastle | 0 | Big Piney | 33 | 2A QF | CST |
| 1991 | Friday, September 6, 1991 | Moorcroft | 34 | Newcastle | 8 | CST | |
| 1991 | Friday, September 13, 1991 | Lead (SD) | 14 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 1991 | Friday, September 20, 1991 | Newcastle | 23 | Custer (SD) | 0 | CST | |
| 1991 | Friday, September 27, 1991 | Lovell | 22 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1991 | Friday, October 4, 1991 | Buffalo | 35 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1991 | Friday, October 11, 1991 | Newcastle | 45 | Glenrock | 20 | CST | |
| 1991 | Saturday, October 19, 1991 | Newcastle | 34 | Wright | 6 | CST | |
| 1991 | Saturday, October 26, 1991 | Newcastle | 0 | Thermopolis | 38 | 2A QF | CST |
| 1992 | Friday, September 4, 1992 | Newcastle | 19 | Moorcroft | 12 | CST | |
| 1992 | Friday, September 11, 1992 | Newcastle | 16 | Lead (SD) | 27 | CST | |
| 1992 | Friday, September 18, 1992 | Custer (SD) | 26 | Newcastle | 22 | CST | |
| 1992 | Friday, September 25, 1992 | Newcastle | 0 | Lovell | 22 | CST | |
| 1992 | Friday, October 2, 1992 | Newcastle | 8 | Buffalo | 14 | CST | |
| 1992 | Friday, October 9, 1992 | Glenrock | 7 | Newcastle | 49 | CST | |
| 1992 | Friday, October 16, 1992 | Wheatland | 21 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1992 | Saturday, October 24, 1992 | Newcastle | 6 | Kemmerer | 54 | 2A QF | CST |
| 1993 | Friday, September 3, 1993 | Moorcroft | 18 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1993 | Friday, September 10, 1993 | Lead (SD) | 38 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1993 | Friday, September 17, 1993 | Newcastle | 6 | Custer (SD) | 15 | CST | |
| 1993 | Friday, September 24, 1993 | Buffalo | 40 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1993 | Friday, October 1, 1993 | Lovell | 31 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1993 | Monday, October 11, 1993 | Newcastle | 44 | Glenrock | 0 | CST | |
| 1993 | Friday, October 15, 1993 | Newcastle | 14 | Thermopolis | 34 | CST | |
| 1993 | Friday, October 22, 1993 | Newcastle | 0 | Kemmerer | 52 | 2A QF | CST |
| 1994 | Friday, September 2, 1994 | Newcastle | 19 | Moorcroft | 0 | CST | |
| 1994 | Friday, September 9, 1994 | Newcastle | 25 | Lead (SD) | 8 | RR | |
| 1994 | Friday, September 16, 1994 | Custer (SD) | 22 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 1994 | Friday, September 23, 1994 | Newcastle | 0 | Buffalo | 28 | CST | |
| 1994 | Friday, September 30, 1994 | Newcastle | 14 | Lovell | 34 | CST | |
| 1994 | Friday, October 7, 1994 | Glenrock | 12 | Newcastle | 26 | CST | |
| 1994 | Friday, October 14, 1994 | Thermopolis | 37 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1994 | Saturday, October 22, 1994 | Newcastle | 0 | Kemmerer | 35 | 2A QF | CST |
| 1995 | Friday, September 1, 1995 | Moorcroft | 20 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1995 | Friday, September 8, 1995 | Lead (SD) | 14 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 1995 | Friday, September 15, 1995 | Newcastle | 7 | Douglas | 14 | CST | |
| 1995 | Friday, September 22, 1995 | Buffalo | 15 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1995 | Friday, September 29, 1995 | Lovell | 12 | Newcastle | 18 | CST | |
| 1995 | Friday, October 6, 1995 | Newcastle | 2 | Glenrock | 6 | CST | |
| 1995 | Friday, October 13, 1995 | Newcastle | 7 | Thermopolis | 25 | CST | |
| 1995 | Saturday, October 21, 1995 | Newcastle | 14 | Mountain View | 55 | 2A QF | CST |
| 1996 | Friday, September 6, 1996 | Newcastle | 0 | Moorcroft | 28 | CST | |
| 1996 | Friday, September 13, 1996 | Newcastle | 14 | Sundance | 41 | CST | |
| 1996 | Friday, September 20, 1996 | Douglas | 38 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 1996 | Friday, September 27, 1996 | Newcastle | 15 | Buffalo | 37 | CST | |
| 1996 | Friday, October 4, 1996 | Newcastle | 19 | Lovell | 8 | CST | |
| 1996 | Friday, October 11, 1996 | Glenrock | 32 | Newcastle | 20 | CST | |
| 1996 | Friday, October 18, 1996 | Thermopolis | 43 | Newcastle | 23 | CST | |
| 1996 | Saturday, October 26, 1996 | Newcastle | 27 | Kemmerer | 26 | 2A QF | CST |
| 1996 | Saturday, November 2, 1996 | Newcastle | 16 | Thermopolis | 18 | 2A SF | CST |
| 1997 | Friday, September 5, 1997 | Hot Springs (SD) | 53 | Newcastle | 28 | CST | |
| 1997 | Friday, September 12, 1997 | Newcastle | 0 | Lead (SD) | 27 | RR | |
| 1997 | Friday, September 19, 1997 | Newcastle | 20 | Douglas | 42 | CST | |
| 1997 | Friday, September 26, 1997 | Buffalo | 17 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 1997 | Friday, October 3, 1997 | Lovell | 12 | Newcastle | 18 | CST | |
| 1997 | Friday, October 10, 1997 | Newcastle | 40 | Glenrock | 12 | CST | |
| 1997 | Friday, October 17, 1997 | Newcastle | 26 | Thermopolis | 32 | CST | |
| 1997 | Friday, October 24, 1997 | Wyoming Indian | Newcastle | canceled-snow | CST | ||
| 1998 | Friday, September 4, 1998 | Lead (SD) | 34 | Newcastle | 21 | CST | |
| 1998 | Friday, September 11, 1998 | Newcastle | 22 | Hot Springs (SD) | 19 | CST | |
| 1998 | Friday, September 18, 1998 | Douglas | 27 | Newcastle | 17 | CST | |
| 1998 | Friday, September 25, 1998 | Newcastle | 17 | Buffalo | 36 | CST | |
| 1998 | Friday, October 2, 1998 | Newcastle | 13 | Lovell | 31 | NNLJ | |
| 1998 | Friday, October 9, 1998 | Glenrock | 24 | Newcastle | 31 | 2OT | CST |
| 1998 | Friday, October 16, 1998 | Thermopolis | 14 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 1999 | Friday, September 3, 1999 | Moorcroft | 0 | Newcastle | 41 | CST | |
| 1999 | Saturday, September 11, 1999 | Newcastle | 15 | Lead (SD) | 35 | RR | |
| 1999 | Friday, September 17, 1999 | Newcastle | 17 | Douglas | 42 | CST | |
| 1999 | Friday, September 24, 1999 | Buffalo | 17 | Newcastle | 16 | CST | |
| 1999 | Friday, October 1, 1999 | Lovell | 38 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 1999 | Friday, October 8, 1999 | Newcastle | 7 | Glenrock | 14 | CST | |
| 1999 | Friday, October 15, 1999 | Newcastle | 35 | Thermopolis | 20 | CST | |
| 1999 | Friday, October 22, 1999 | Newcastle | 11 | Mountain View | 27 | 2A QF | CST |
| 2000 | Friday, September 1, 2000 | Newcastle | 17 | Moorcroft | 16 | CST | |
| 2000 | Saturday, September 9, 2000 | Newcastle | 12 | Lead (SD) | 46 | CST | |
| 2000 | Friday, September 15, 2000 | Douglas | 27 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 2000 | Friday, September 22, 2000 | Newcastle | 0 | Buffalo | 20 | CST | |
| 2000 | Friday, September 29, 2000 | Newcastle | 0 | Lovell | 41 | CST | |
| 2000 | Friday, October 6, 2000 | Glenrock | 31 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2000 | Friday, October 13, 2000 | Newcastle | 7 | Thermopolis | 20 | CST/WHSAA | |
| 2001 | Friday, August 24, 2001 | Newcastle | 16 | Moorcroft | 8 | CST | |
| 2001 | Friday, August 31, 2001 | Buffalo | 19 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 2001 | Friday, September 7, 2001 | Newcastle | 6 | Lead (SD) | 36 | CST | |
| 2001 | Friday, September 14, 2001 | Newcastle | 9 | Thermopolis | 33 | CST | |
| 2001 | Friday, September 21, 2001 | Newcastle | 6 | Wheatland | 41 | CST | |
| 2001 | Friday, September 28, 2001 | Torrington | 18 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2001 | Friday, October 5, 2001 | Newcastle | 6 | Douglas | 32 | CST | |
| 2001 | Friday, October 12, 2001 | Glenrock | 34 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 2001 | Friday, October 19, 2001 | Jackson | 20 | Newcastle | 6 | 4A Consolation | CST |
| 2002 | Friday, August 30, 2002 | Moorcroft | 8 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2002 | Friday, September 6, 2002 | Newcastle | 0 | Buffalo | 46 | CST | |
| 2002 | Friday, September 13, 2002 | Newcastle | 0 | Lead (SD) | 49 | CST/WHSAA | |
| 2002 | Friday, September 20, 2002 | Thermopolis | 48 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2002 | Friday, September 27, 2002 | Wheatland | 66 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2002 | Friday, October 4, 2002 | Douglas | 63 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 2002 | Friday, October 11, 2002 | Newcastle | 7 | Torrington | 47 | CST | |
| 2002 | Friday, October 18, 2002 | Newcastle | 0 | Glenrock | 47 | CST | |
| 2002 | Friday, October 25, 2002 | Newcastle | 20 | Torrington | 47 | 4A Consolation | CST |
| 2003 | Friday, August 29, 2003 | Newcastle | 0 | Thermopolis | 35 | CST | |
| 2003 | Friday, September 5, 2003 | Buffalo | 38 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2003 | Friday, September 12, 2003 | Custer (SD) | 31 | Newcastle | 28 | CST | |
| 2003 | Saturday, September 20, 2003 | Newcastle | 19 | Lead (SD) | 47 | CST | |
| 2003 | Friday, September 26, 2003 | Newcastle | 8 | Wheatland | 49 | CST | |
| 2003 | Friday, October 3, 2003 | Newcastle | 20 | Douglas | 47 | CST | |
| 2003 | Friday, October 10, 2003 | Torrington | 33 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2003 | Friday, October 17, 2003 | Glenrock | 33 | Newcastle | 20 | CST | |
| 2004 | Friday, August 27, 2004 | Newcastle | 13 | Rawlins | 21 | CST | |
| 2004 | Friday, September 3, 2004 | Lead (SD) | 23 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2004 | Friday, September 10, 2004 | Newcastle | 7 | Custer (SD) | 26 | CST | |
| 2004 | Friday, September 17, 2004 | Buffalo | 49 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 2004 | Friday, September 24, 2004 | Wheatland | 20 | Newcastle | 34 | CST | |
| 2004 | Friday, October 1, 2004 | Douglas | 40 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 2004 | Friday, October 8, 2004 | Newcastle | 7 | Torrington | 40 | CST | |
| 2004 | Friday, October 15, 2004 | Newcastle | 22 | Glenrock | 26 | CST | |
| 2005 | Friday, September 2, 2005 | Custer (SD) | 31 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 2005 | Friday, September 9, 2005 | Newcastle | 19 | Lead (SD) | 34 | CST | |
| 2005 | Friday, September 16, 2005 | Newcastle | 0 | Glenrock | 45 | CST | |
| 2005 | Friday, September 23, 2005 | Greybull | 36 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 2005 | Friday, September 30, 2005 | Newcastle | 22 | Thermopolis | 25 | CST | |
| 2005 | Friday, October 7, 2005 | Torrington | 52 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 2005 | Friday, October 14, 2005 | Lovell | 61 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 2005 | Friday, October 21, 2005 | Newcastle | 28 | Tongue River | 54 | CST | |
| 2006 | Friday, September 1, 2006 | Newcastle | 0 | Custer (SD) | 39 | CST | |
| 2006 | Friday, September 8, 2006 | Tongue River | 23 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2006 | Friday, September 15, 2006 | Glenrock | 6 | Newcastle | 17 | CST | |
| 2006 | Friday, September 22, 2006 | Newcastle | 40 | Greybull | 6 | CST | |
| 2006 | Friday, September 29, 2006 | Thermopolis | 0 | Newcastle | 41 | CST | |
| 2006 | Friday, October 6, 2006 | Newcastle | 41 | Torrington | 14 | CST | |
| 2006 | Friday, October 13, 2006 | Wheatland | 8 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 2006 | Friday, October 20, 2006 | Newcastle | 26 | Lovell | 0 | CST | |
| 2006 | Friday, October 27, 2006 | Big Piney | 12 | Newcastle | 6 | 3A QF | CST |
| 2007 | Friday, August 31, 2007 | Custer (SD) | 28 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 2007 | Friday, September 7, 2007 | Moorcroft | 6 | Newcastle | 28 | CST | |
| 2007 | Friday, September 14, 2007 | Newcastle | 6 | Wright | 41 | CST | |
| 2007 | Friday, September 21, 2007 | Lovell | 28 | Newcastle | 21 | CST | |
| 2007 | Friday, September 28, 2007 | Newcastle | 14 | Thermopolis | 7 | CST | |
| 2007 | Friday, October 5, 2007 | Torrington | 19 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2007 | Friday, October 12, 2007 | Newcastle | 6 | Wheatland | 40 | CST | |
| 2007 | Friday, October 19, 2007 | Newcastle | 7 | Glenrock | 55 | CST | |
| 2008 | Friday, September 5, 2008 | Newcastle | 14 | Custer (SD) | 37 | CST | |
| 2008 | Friday, September 12, 2008 | Wheatland | 28 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2008 | Friday, September 19, 2008 | Thermopolis | 13 | Newcastle | 35 | CST | |
| 2008 | Friday, September 26, 2008 | Newcastle | 0 | Moorcroft | 24 | CST | |
| 2008 | Friday, October 3, 2008 | Wright | 6 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2008 | Friday, October 10, 2008 | Newcastle | 0 | Lovell | 40 | CST | |
| 2008 | Friday, October 17, 2008 | Glenrock | 42 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 2008 | Friday, October 24, 2008 | Newcastle | 23 | Torrington | 53 | CST | |
| 2009 | Friday, August 28, 2009 | Custer (SD) | 14 | Newcastle | 15 | 2OT | CST |
| 2009 | Friday, September 4, 2009 | Southeast | 33 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2009 | Saturday, September 12, 2009 | Newcastle | 19 | Moorcroft | 26 | CST | |
| 2009 | Friday, September 18, 2009 | Burns | 20 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2009 | Friday, September 25, 2009 | Newcastle | 0 | Wright | 22 | CST | |
| 2009 | Friday, October 2, 2009 | Newcastle | 12 | Glenrock | 37 | CST | |
| 2009 | Saturday, October 10, 2009 | Tongue River | 7 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2009 | Friday, October 16, 2009 | Newcastle | 28 | Thermopolis | 42 | CST | |
| 2009 | Friday, October 23, 2009 | Big Horn | 28 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 2010 | Friday, August 27, 2010 | Newcastle | 12 | Custer (SD) | 15 | CST | |
| 2010 | Friday, September 3, 2010 | Newcastle | 7 | Southeast | 27 | CST/TT | |
| 2010 | Friday, September 10, 2010 | Moorcroft | 6 | Newcastle | 36 | CST | |
| 2010 | Friday, September 17, 2010 | Newcastle | 10 | Burns | 6 | CST | |
| 2010 | Friday, September 24, 2010 | Wright | 28 | Newcastle | 21 | OT | CST |
| 2010 | Friday, October 1, 2010 | Glenrock | 6 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 2010 | Friday, October 8, 2010 | Newcastle | 8 | Tongue River | 6 | CST | |
| 2010 | Friday, October 15, 2010 | Thermopolis | 47 | Newcastle | 34 | CST | |
| 2010 | Friday, October 22, 2010 | Newcastle | 13 | Big Horn | 35 | CST | |
| 2010 | Friday, October 29, 2010 | Newcastle | 14 | Greybull | 30 | 2A QF | CST |
| 2011 | Saturday, August 27, 2011 | Custer (SD) | 26 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 2011 | Friday, September 2, 2011 | Southeast | 13 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2011 | Friday, September 9, 2011 | Newcastle | 28 | Moorcroft | 6 | CST | |
| 2011 | Friday, September 16, 2011 | Burns | 6 | Newcastle | 31 | CST | |
| 2011 | Friday, September 23, 2011 | Newcastle | 20 | Wright | 0 | CST | |
| 2011 | Friday, September 30, 2011 | Newcastle | 14 | Glenrock | 33 | CST | |
| 2011 | Friday, October 14, 2011 | Newcastle | 33 | Wheatland | 0 | CST | |
| 2011 | Friday, October 21, 2011 | Big Horn | 21 | Newcastle | 35 | CST | |
| 2011 | Saturday, October 29, 2011 | Thermopolis | 0 | Newcastle | 28 | 2A QF | CST |
| 2011 | Friday, November 4, 2011 | Newcastle | 20 | Lovell | 23 | 2A SF | CST |
| 2012 | Friday, August 24, 2012 | Newcastle | 30 | Custer (SD) | 14 | CST | |
| 2012 | Friday, August 31, 2012 | Newcastle | 17 | Southeast | 12 | CST | |
| 2012 | Friday, September 7, 2012 | Moorcroft | 6 | Newcastle | 30 | CST | |
| 2012 | Friday, September 14, 2012 | Newcastle | 29 | Burns | 7 | CST | |
| 2012 | Friday, September 21, 2012 | Wright | 6 | Newcastle | 44 | CST | |
| 2012 | Friday, September 28, 2012 | Glenrock | 8 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 2012 | Friday, October 5, 2012 | Newcastle | 48 | Tongue River | 6 | CST | |
| 2012 | Friday, October 12, 2012 | Wheatland | 13 | Newcastle | 37 | CST | |
| 2012 | Friday, October 19, 2012 | Newcastle | 6 | Big Horn | 55 | CST | |
| 2012 | Friday, October 26, 2012 | Mountain View | 13 | Newcastle | 43 | 2A QF | CST |
| 2012 | Saturday, November 3, 2012 | Newcastle | 6 | Lyman | 32 | 2A SF | CST |
| 2013 | Friday, August 30, 2013 | Custer (SD) | 20 | Newcastle | 13 | CST | |
| 2013 | Friday, September 6, 2013 | Lusk | 26 | Newcastle | 22 | CST | |
| 2013 | Friday, September 13, 2013 | Big Horn | 50 | Newcastle | 43 | CST | |
| 2013 | Friday, September 20, 2013 | Newcastle | 63 | Moorcroft | 0 | CST | |
| 2013 | Friday, September 27, 2013 | Burns | 40 | Newcastle | 19 | CST | |
| 2013 | Monday, October 7, 2013 | Newcastle | 41 | Wright | 16 | CST | |
| 2013 | Friday, October 11, 2013 | Newcastle | 34 | Glenrock | 12 | CST | |
| 2013 | Friday, October 18, 2013 | Tongue River | 15 | Newcastle | 56 | CST | |
| 2013 | Thursday, October 24, 2013 | Newcastle | 31 | Wheatland | 20 | CST | |
| 2013 | Friday, November 1, 2013 | Newcastle | 12 | Mountain View | 20 | 2A QF | CST |
| 2014 | Friday, August 29, 2014 | Newcastle | 8 | Custer (SD) | 30 | CST | |
| 2014 | Thursday, September 4, 2014 | Campbell County JV | 28 | Newcastle | 50 | CST | |
| 2014 | Friday, September 12, 2014 | Newcastle | 32 | Burns | 18 | at Cheyenne South | CST |
| 2014 | Friday, September 19, 2014 | Wheatland | 12 | Newcastle | 16 | CST | |
| 2014 | Friday, September 26, 2014 | Newcastle | 34 | Greybull | 14 | CST | |
| 2014 | Friday, October 3, 2014 | Wright | 7 | Newcastle | 50 | CST | |
| 2014 | Friday, October 10, 2014 | Newcastle | 30 | Glenrock | 0 | CST | |
| 2014 | Friday, October 17, 2014 | Big Horn | 49 | Newcastle | 14 | CST | |
| 2014 | Friday, October 24, 2014 | Newcastle | 34 | Thermopolis | 19 | CST | |
| 2014 | Friday, October 31, 2014 | Greybull | 14 | Newcastle | 38 | 2A QF | CST |
| 2014 | Friday, November 7, 2014 | Newcastle | 14 | Mountain View | 52 | 2A SF | CST |
| 2015 | Friday, August 28, 2015 | Custer (SD) | 14 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 2015 | Friday, September 4, 2015 | Newcastle | 50 | Lead-Deadwood (SD) | 12 | CST | |
| 2015 | Friday, September 11, 2015 | Burns | 7 | Newcastle | 56 | CST | |
| 2015 | Friday, September 18, 2015 | Newcastle | 0 | Wheatland | 52 | CST | |
| 2015 | Friday, September 25, 2015 | Greybull | 7 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 2015 | Friday, October 2, 2015 | Newcastle | 60 | Wright | 12 | CST | |
| 2015 | Friday, October 9, 2015 | Glenrock | 40 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2015 | Friday, October 16, 2015 | Newcastle | 0 | Big Horn | 49 | CST | |
| 2015 | Friday, October 23, 2015 | Thermopolis | 28 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2016 | Friday, August 26, 2016 | Newcastle | 48 | Custer (SD) | 2 | CST | |
| 2016 | Friday, September 2, 2016 | Upton-Sundance | 34 | Newcastle | 21 | CST | |
| 2016 | Friday, September 9, 2016 | Newcastle | 36 | Moorcroft | 14 | CST | |
| 2016 | Friday, September 16, 2016 | Glenrock | 34 | Newcastle | 7 | CST | |
| 2016 | Friday, September 23, 2016 | Newcastle | 10 | Big Horn | 40 | CST | |
| 2016 | Friday, September 30, 2016 | Wheatland | 28 | Newcastle | 27 | CST | |
| 2016 | Saturday, October 8, 2016 | Newcastle | 45 | Big Piney | 26 | CST | |
| 2016 | Friday, October 14, 2016 | Newcastle | 50 | Thermopolis | 14 | CST | |
| 2016 | Friday, October 21, 2016 | Burns | 25 | Newcastle | 49 | CST | |
| 2016 | Friday, October 28, 2016 | Newcastle | 31 | Mountain View | 28 | 2A QF-2OT | CST |
| 2016 | Friday, November 4, 2016 | Newcastle | 7 | Big Horn | 27 | 2A SF | CST |
| 2017 | Friday, August 25, 2017 | Custer (SD) | 0 | Newcastle | 42 | CST | |
| 2017 | Friday, September 1, 2017 | Newcastle | 22 | Lovell | 20 | CST | |
| 2017 | Friday, September 8, 2017 | Newcastle | 13 | Upton-Sundance | 28 | at Upton | CST |
| 2017 | Friday, September 15, 2017 | Torrington | 55 | Newcastle | 10 | CST | |
| 2017 | Friday, September 22, 2017 | Newcastle | 21 | Glenrock | 49 | CST | |
| 2017 | Friday, September 29, 2017 | Newcastle | 44 | Burns | 16 | CST | |
| 2017 | Friday, October 6, 2017 | Moorcroft | 8 | Newcastle | 35 | CST | |
| 2017 | Friday, October 13, 2017 | Newcastle | 34 | Wheatland | 40 | CST | |
| 2017 | Friday, October 20, 2017 | Thermopolis | 12 | Newcastle | 48 | CST | |
| 2017 | Friday, October 27, 2017 | Newcastle | 14 | Big Piney | 42 | 2A QF | WHSAA |
| 2018 | Friday, August 24, 2018 | Newcastle | 6 | Custer (SD) | 35 | CST | |
| 2018 | Friday, August 31, 2018 | Wheatland | 49 | Newcastle | 12 | CST | |
| 2018 | Friday, September 7, 2018 | Glenrock | 48 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 2018 | Friday, September 14, 2018 | Newcastle | Rocky Mountain | Newcastle win by forfeit | CST | ||
| 2018 | Friday, September 21, 2018 | Newcastle | 7 | Moorcroft | 26 | CST | |
| 2018 | Friday, September 28, 2018 | Lusk | 16 | Newcastle | 6 | CST | |
| 2018 | Friday, October 5, 2018 | Thermopolis | 66 | Newcastle | 0 | CST | |
| 2018 | Friday, October 12, 2018 | Newcastle | 8 | Burns | 54 | CST | |
| 2018 | Friday, October 19, 2018 | Newcastle | 8 | Buffalo | 56 | CST | |
| 2019 | Friday, August 30, 2019 | Hot Springs (SD) | 32 | Newcastle | 2 | WHSAA | |
| 2019 | Friday, September 6, 2019 | Newcastle | 20 | Wheatland | 41 | WHSAA | |
| 2019 | Friday, September 13, 2019 | Newcastle | 7 | Glenrock | 22 | WHSAA | |
| 2019 | Friday, September 20, 2019 | Rocky Mountain | 29 | Newcastle | 13 | WHSAA | |
| 2019 | Friday, September 27, 2019 | Moorcroft | 6 | Newcastle | 32 | WHSAA | |
| 2019 | Friday, October 4, 2019 | Newcastle | 8 | Lusk | 60 | WHSAA | |
| 2019 | Friday, October 11, 2019 | Newcastle | 16 | Thermopolis | 67 | WHSAA | |
| 2019 | Friday, October 18, 2019 | Burns | 46 | Newcastle | 0 | WHSAA | |
| 2019 | Friday, October 25, 2019 | Buffalo | 62 | Newcastle | 14 | WHSAA | |
| 2020 | Friday, August 28, 2020 | Newcastle | 7 | Hot Springs (SD) | 13 | WHSAA | |
| 2020 | Friday, September 4, 2020 | Newcastle | Buffalo | canceled-COVID-19 | WHSAA | ||
| 2020 | Friday, September 11, 2020 | Upton-Sundance | 41 | Newcastle | 0 | WHSAA | |
| 2020 | Friday, September 18, 2020 | Big Horn | 35 | Newcastle | 12 | WHSAA | |
| 2020 | Friday, September 25, 2020 | Newcastle | 0 | Tongue River | 30 | WHSAA | |
| 2020 | Friday, October 2, 2020 | Newcastle | 7 | Glenrock | 34 | WHSAA | |
| 2020 | Friday, October 9, 2020 | Torrington | 49 | Newcastle | 14 | WHSAA | |
| 2020 | Friday, October 23, 2020 | Newcastle | 13 | Wheatland | 45 | WHSAA | |
| 2020 | Thursday, October 29, 2020 | Burns | 20 | Newcastle | 12 | WHSAA | |
| 2021 | Friday, August 27, 2021 | Hot Springs (SD) | 23 | Newcastle | 0 | WHSAA | |
| 2021 | Friday, September 3, 2021 | Buffalo | 38 | Newcastle | 0 | WHSAA | |
| 2021 | Thursday, September 9, 2021 | Newcastle | 6 | Upton-Sundance | 28 | at Sundance | WHSAA |
| 2021 | Friday, September 17, 2021 | Newcastle | 0 | Big Horn | 20 | WHSAA | |
| 2021 | Friday, September 24, 2021 | Tongue River | 17 | Newcastle | 20 | OT | WHSAA |
| 2021 | Friday, October 1, 2021 | Glenrock | 6 | Newcastle | 25 | WHSAA | |
| 2021 | Friday, October 8, 2021 | Newcastle | 22 | Torrington | 35 | WHSAA | |
| 2021 | Friday, October 15, 2021 | Newcastle | 10 | Burns | 6 | WHSAA | |
| 2021 | Friday, October 22, 2021 | Wheatland | 40 | Newcastle | 38 | WHSAA | |
| 2022 | Friday, September 2, 2022 | Newcastle | 8 | Buffalo | 27 | WHSAA | |
| 2022 | Friday, September 9, 2022 | Newcastle | 20 | Wheatland | 18 | 2OT | WHSAA |
| 2022 | Friday, September 16, 2022 | Burns | 42 | Newcastle | 15 | WHSAA | |
| 2022 | Friday, September 23, 2022 | Newcastle | 7 | Tongue River | 30 | WHSAA | |
| 2022 | Thursday, September 29, 2022 | Upton-Sundance | 14 | Newcastle | 32 | WHSAA | |
| 2022 | Friday, October 7, 2022 | Big Horn | 59 | Newcastle | 26 | WHSAA | |
| 2022 | Friday, October 14, 2022 | Newcastle | 26 | Glenrock | 12 | WHSAA | |
| 2022 | Friday, October 21, 2022 | Torrington | 14 | Newcastle | 39 | WHSAA | |
| 2022 | Friday, October 28, 2022 | Newcastle | 14 | Lovell | 47 | 2A QF | WHSAA |
| 2023 | Friday, September 1, 2023 | Buffalo | 49 | Newcastle | 12 | WP | |
| 2023 | Friday, September 8, 2023 | Wheatland | 22 | Newcastle | 14 | WP | |
| 2023 | Friday, September 15, 2023 | Newcastle | 28 | Burns | 0 | WP | |
| 2023 | Friday, September 22, 2023 | Tongue River | 54 | Newcastle | 7 | WP | |
| 2023 | Friday, September 29, 2023 | Newcastle | 17 | Upton-Sundance | 28 | at Upton | WP |
| 2023 | Friday, October 6, 2023 | Newcastle | 16 | Big Horn | 55 | WP | |
| 2023 | Friday, October 13, 2023 | Glenrock | 13 | Newcastle | 35 | WP | |
| 2023 | Friday, October 20, 2023 | Newcastle | 0 | Torrington | 36 | WP | |
| 2024 | Friday, September 6, 2024 | Newcastle | 14 | Buffalo | 42 | WP | |
| 2024 | Friday, September 13, 2024 | Upton-Sundance | 6 | Newcastle | 48 | WP | |
| 2024 | Friday, September 20, 2024 | Newcastle | 7 | Big Horn | 50 | WP | |
| 2024 | Saturday, September 28, 2024 | Tongue River | 12 | Newcastle | 34 | WP | |
| 2024 | Friday, October 4, 2024 | Newcastle | 28 | Glenrock | 6 | WP | |
| 2024 | Friday, October 11, 2024 | Moorcroft | 0 | Newcastle | 57 | WP | |
| 2024 | Saturday, October 19, 2024 | Burns | 14 | Newcastle | 49 | WP | |
| 2024 | Friday, October 25, 2024 | Newcastle | 40 | Wheatland | 13 | WP | |
| 2024 | Friday, November 1, 2024 | Cokeville | 28 | Newcastle | 20 | 2A QF | WHSAA |
| Season | Date | Away Team | Away Score | Home Team | Home Score | Notes | Source |